MovieChat Forums > Silsiilay (2005) Discussion > Rate the 3 episodes seperately!

Rate the 3 episodes seperately!


I saw the film, and found it quite hard to rate the movie as a whole because my opinion of the individual stories are so different from each other.

My rating would be:

- Bhumika-episode: 7,5 (above average, acting seemed not sincere, could have been great with good actors, actress Divya Dutta wasted)
- Riya Sen-episode: 4 (boring, bad acting, too long)
- Tabu-episode: 9 (excellent acting, excellent screenplay, everything excellent)

What do you say?

reply

I think that,

Bhumika- 10/10 (Flawless story, nice acting, good represtantion)
Riya Sen- 1/10 (Just Bad)
Tabu- 5/10 (Not unusual)

reply

bhumika-9/10 (i think it was great except for some parts of bhumika's acting)
riya sen-4/10 (it was kinda boring and senseless)
tabu-7/10 (it was good especially the acting)

overall the movie was alrite though i thought the ending was very abrupt..i felt like it left me hanging!!!

reply

Bhumika - 8/10 (it was because of this episode that I watched the film to the end)
Riya sen - 4/10 (I hated the male characters)
Tabu - 7/10 (very hot actress !)

reply

Bhumika- 3/10 (I was lost with her story..)
Riya sen - 6/10 (Didn't mind her story just that the guys are weird in her one)
Tabu- 8/10 (I wanted more tabu and less of the others.. I loved her in this movie)

reply

my rating:
bhumila episode: 4.5
riya episode: 2
tabu episode: 9 (director should have focused on this one more)

reply


Bhumika - 7/10 - story was too confusing and hard to follow.
Riya - 7/10 - beautiful eye-candy actors, simple story line.
Tabu - 9.5/10 - story not original, but well acted emotions by all, esp Tabu!
(I wish she had a lot more screen roles in indian films - underrated and underused talent!)

...Jadoo, Jadoo, Ladoo, Jadoo...

reply

bhumikla 4.5/10
riya 1.5/10
tabu 9/0 and this majorly goes to her performance

reply