MovieChat Forums > Project Runway (2004) Discussion > Did Rik deserve the "no voice" edit?

Did Rik deserve the "no voice" edit?


I thought his vibe the whole season was a West Coast-punk rock thing and that's exactly what his collection was. It should have been Roberi and Rik for the final two (even though I loved Laurence's work throughout the season).

reply

Definitely agree with you, and I don't get the whole "chameleon" thing as being a drawback. After all, doesn't being a "chameleon" propel some of the biggest stars to becoming ICONIC?

reply

Well there's a big difference between an actor being a chameleon and a designer being all over the place. Which iconic designer has a hard to define style?

-
Consider the daffodil. And while you're doing that I'll be over here looking through your stuff.

reply

I definitely didn't see Rik as being eliminated first on that finale. As much as I adore Erin on a personal level, her clothes don't speak to me. Her own personal style is way better than the stuff she creates.

reply