MovieChat Forums > Doctor Who (2006) Discussion > Something i just thought of with the fem...

Something i just thought of with the female doctor issue.


First, i am against the doctor being female, not for sexist reasons but because the doctor has always been established as a male. That's who the character is. Never once, in any regeneration, has the doctor said "am i a man or a woman?". It's never come up before until recently. This change is clearly a product of our time and not in a good way.

That being said, one way they could have brought on a female doctor and done some damage control would have been to establish that, when the doctor was given his additional regenerations, because they weren't originally his own, they carried some aberrant DNA which could result in unpredictable effects. This would explain the presence of a female doctor while still maintaining the Doctor's innate "maleness".

A big concern i have is that every episode is going to be about how the doctor is female - in the same way that, when Ellen came out of the closet, almost every episode after that was about homosexuality and lesbianism.

reply

The Doctor is a bloomin' alien. Not a human. Male and female really doesn't apply.

reply

Clearly it does. Time Lords get married - male to female - and have kids (presumably the same way earth couples do). There is obviously a parallel. Plus, if it doesn't apply, why did the Doctor always look like a man? Coincidence? And why did the Master change his name to Missy when he regenerated?

reply

I have no idea but Gallifrey isn't Earth and Gallifreyans are not human. Allow me to rephrase; male and female as it applies to humans does not apply to aliens.

reply

I just gave you evidence that it does. What is your proof that it doesn't?

reply

That wasn't proof though. Visualize on the other hand...

reply

@naDaht

Actually, in The Night of the Doctor, Eight was given the choice by the Sisterhood of Karn to pick ‘male’ or ‘female’.

In The Doctor’s Wife we learn of another Time Lord named The Corsair, who was ‘male’ or ‘female’ during different incarnations (and was apparently a bad girl in one, and a strapping big bloke in another).

The Master, an equally always male time lord, became Missy (self referred to as a Time Lady).

So basically, your attempt at an argument is invalid.
Gender has been identified for two other Time Lord's (Lady’s), and a third set the stage for ‘our’ Time Lord's gender change.

reply

And as far as we know, "male" and "female" could just be the TARDIS doing a "for lack of a better word!" translation. But even if it isn't, the Doctor is a freaking alien with two hearts, a brain the size of a planet, who travels in space and time and doesn't really die but regenerate in to a completely new person. But it's soooooo unrealistic that next, the Doctor grows boobs.

reply

And I don't care if the Doctor grows boobs on her back and has purple nipples on her toes.
My response was to point out that gender has been mentioned on previous occasion :-)

reply