MovieChat Forums > Protocols of Zion (2005) Discussion > WOW!!!!!!!!!!

WOW!!!!!!!!!!

posted 18 years ago by little-thistle
4 replies | jump to latest

I never thought i would read so many racist and dumb statements about a film based on the ideas of those interviewed and what they truly believed.

I am not a jew, but I am evolutionary biologist. There used to be a time in america when jews and christians respected one another more.
Maybe you guys who thought all that was a joke or it was a whiney jew thing can visit a neo-nazi site, or a holocost site, and then take visit to a mennonite church.

What you understand and what you know of the myth of the Illuminati (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordo_Templi_Orientis) and the NWO is a bunch of nonsense that makes sense out of myths.....you all sound like copy cats of David Icke, who believes he is Jesus Incarnate.

And, just like Saddam Hussain had weapons of mass destruction, was buying yellow cake uranium, and hanging with Osama, and planned the attack. You are making nonsensical connections, this documentary is based on books published, people interviewed, holocost suvivors, the antidefimation league. C'mon people. You need to use scientific method not the Internet to buy into beliefs.

What have you learned in school/college WASPS?
Did they teach you about slavery?

[–] fuzzy_wunz 17 years ago

I would never promote hate. From your comment, you seek to defuse hate with reason. Fair enough, but you propose that the ADL and holocaust survivors represent truths in and of themselves. Furthermore, you then appeal to the scientific method without ever employing it yourself. In the end, you simply come across as a sympathizer (a scientifically unreasonable position).

A flawed argument for tolerance tempered by reason is still a flawed argument (however noble you think it may be). And the most that a flawed argument could ever hope to elicit is an emotional and unreasonable response.

[–] 17 years ago

[deleted]

[–] mcgryboski 17 years ago

It was not even that. I think the whole documentary was about extremism in general, how various fringe groups use dubious sources to prop up their beliefs and how many false ideologies, organizations and books, can be created from lies.

Levin also showed Jewish extremists, people who wanted all Arabs to be kicked out of the Levant. I felt that he showed these people in the same light as the White Supremacists and Pro-Palestinian folk.

The only people that had sense in the entire movie were the Christian evangelicals and Messianic Jews.

[–] 17 years ago

[deleted]