MovieChat Forums > V for Vendetta (2006) Discussion > Paranoid leftist film that highlights le...

Paranoid leftist film that highlights leftist ignorance


And contradiction. First of all to be inspired by
Guy Fawkes is hilarious, given that he was a racist ultraconservative catholic who hated religious tolerance.
Secondly it implies fascism is anti Islam, when in fact the opposite is true, Adolf Hitler was very fond of islamism and the palestinian movement.
Most homosexuals in the UK fear muslims more than those from Tunbridge Wells.
The church of England is loyal to the monarch not to the government, the idea it would be supporting a republican government is absurd.
Why would a homosexual revere the Qur'an?, much like a jew revering Mein Kampf.
Just face it lefties, you've won and its more likely that this country will be installing gulags to cure people who suffer from conservatism than any right wing regime being formed.
Is it me or do lefties tend to lump anyone they disagree with as "right wing" be they conservatives , classical liberals, libertarians, neo cons, thatcherites, Powellites, nationalists and fascists?

reply

Time for a cup of tea.

reply

mmm, that was a nice cup of tea.

reply

The hypocrisy of your profound ignorance here is, well, not that surprising for a run-of-the-mill right-whinger. This film was adapted from a comic book, completely different in subject, tone and purpose to the movie. If this film stood alone and was original, you might have a point, but it isn't and so all your uninformed points are invalid. But I'm guessing you're not much of a reader, and certainly not of comics?

[truth]I am bisexual. If you dont like that, you can blow me. If you do: same deal.[/truth]

reply

Adapted from a graphic noval whose creater has decredited himself from the film.

reply

It was a comic book series, not graphic novel, and yes, he refused credit for the reason I stated: the subject, tone and purpose of the film was changed during adaptation. I said that. What's your point?

[truth]I am bisexual. If you dont like that, you can blow me. If you do: same deal.[/truth]

reply

What's YOUR point? I was commenting on the film.

reply

My point is that the film didn't invent any of what is shown, they just misinterpreted aspects of the comic book. So saying that it was created as part of a "leftist agenda" is BS, because it was created in the eighties by an anarchist writer and an artist as a neutral exploration of fascism, a reaction to Thatcherism and a tribute to various things, and this film is just a weak, shallow, utterly simplified version of that.

[truth]I am bisexual. If you dont like that, you can blow me. If you do: same deal.[/truth]

reply

I never said it was created as part of a leftist agenda.

reply

Just face it lefties, you've won and its more likely that this country will be installing gulags to cure people who suffer from conservatism than any right wing regime being formed.
Is it me or do lefties tend to lump anyone they disagree with as "right wing" be they conservatives , classical liberals, libertarians, neo cons, thatcherites, Powellites, nationalists and fascists?


[truth]I am bisexual. If you dont like that, you can blow me. If you do: same deal.[/truth]

reply

And? I still did not say the film pushed a leftist agenda.

reply

Then what is it you're saying it's trying to achieve which we've already "won"? (And yes, it is you.)

[truth]I am bisexual. If you dont like that, you can blow me. If you do: same deal.[/truth]

reply

The culture wars and the battle for Britain.

reply

If only side knows it's a war, then it's not a war.

[truth]I am bisexual. If you dont like that, you can blow me. If you do: same deal.[/truth]

reply

The gramcian left knows its a war. The only ones who didn't were ignorant blind conservatives.

reply

The average person wouldn't even have heard of Antonio Gramsci, or know anything about him, and you clearly don't know much about the average person. You're right that conservatives are often ignorant or blind, though.

[truth]I am bisexual. If you dont like that, you can blow me. If you do: same deal.[/truth]

reply

The average person is insignificant, the average person would't have even heard of Alexander the Great, Alfred the Great or the Sun King.

reply

Wrong on the first point, and on all three examples (maybe less so the second and third ones, particularly if the individual was from England or from France, respectively). Also further evidence both that you don't understand the meaning of the original comic, and that you don't understand the average person, as paranoid rightwing cynics typically do not.

"Everybody is special. Everybody. Everybody is a hero, a lover, a fool, a villain, everybody. Everybody has their story to tell…" V.

[truth]I am bisexual. If you dont like that: you can blow me. If you do: same deal.[/truth]

reply

You dont talk to the average person much do you? I couldnt care less whaat the original comic book was about, i am commenting on the film. Most school kids nowadays dont even know who Churchill was.

reply

lol, well that's due to pop-culture. I hate that too, but that's got nothing to do with leftwing politics, it's about money, because crap sells. If you have a problem with this film, it's with the American makers and writers of it, not with anything in the UK.

[truth]I am bisexual. If you dont like that: you can blow me. If you do: same deal.[/truth]

reply

lol, well that's due to pop-culture. I hate that too,


Using a social media discussion of a film and a graphic novel is such a great forum for you to express you disdain of pop culture.



I've lived upon the edge of chance for 20 years or more...
Del Rio's Song

reply

I too hated this movie for all of the reasons you've listed.

I must add, though, that I found that whole "isn't the Koran a lovely book" scene to be particularly repugnant. That's absolutely typical of the Left in Europe - endlessly criticising Christianity and conservatism in the West, while constantly fawning over Islam and "moderate" Muslims (which is usually anyone who is slightly less extreme than the late Osama bin Laden).

reply

Lovely generalizations.

reply

SO, how's gay marriage, or for that matter inter-faith marriage (for Muslim women to non-Muslim men) going in the Islamic world?

reply

How has it been going in Christian society until the most recent generation or two?

Christianity, the two thousand year old culture that gets to take the high ground because it reformed some of its cultural taboos and prejudices in the last few decades.

reply

Yes, it does indeed get to "take the high ground", because it HAS the high ground. Compare that to even the more "moderate" Islamic countries like Iran or Indonesia, where homosexuality is punishable by public flogging (Indonesia), or even hanging (Iran).

reply

You mean moderate Islamic societies that were driven into the hands of the extreme religious bands because of the destabilization of their democracies because the white Christians with the moral high ground felt like them running their economies for their own interests was grounds to topple them in favour of a secular dictator?

Kick people around and they run to the extremists. It happens every time. Its why communist revolution was so popular in Central America - the American backed regimes were just that awful that living under Communist rule was preferable.

Meanwhile civilized British society still censors everything, and chemically castrated its war hero math genius. I presume you've seen the bio pic starring Benedict Cabbage Patch.

Meanwhile in the states a huge list of state governments are doing everything in their power to reverse many of these moral high ground changes because their religious right wing base is potent enough that you can get ahead politically promising that idiotic nonsense. The best part is that 50+ years ago when America hated the Catholics politically it was because they feared they had no respect for the firm separation of church and state. The dogma was that Catholics answered to the Pope and were traitors at heart. Now those same people are extremely opposed to the notion of Separation of Church and State so if anything the shining beacon of moral superiority, the US of A, is regressing in its religious progress towards reason and balance in secular society.

Incidentally even a country like Iran has better paternity leave protections for women than in America.

Its amazing what these savage muslim lands are like. Better female medicine covered by the state in Iran, better access to doctors and education in oppressive Cuba. The moral high ground is treacherous as it often falls away unexpectedly from your feet and suddenly you're looking up at the most unlikely of characters, ones you were promised were beneath you.

reply

It wasn't good up until the last few generations, but it has never, EVER been as bad as it is in muslim countries to this day! While western countries are progressing there, Islamic countries are only regressing more and more.

reply

[deleted]

So, if this is leftist - are you trying to say that the conservatives wants an all controlling government like in the film?

Oh, and just to say, the Gay dude he didn't actually revere the Quran, he only liked it from it's artistic point of view. As arab caligraphy is considered beautiful and artistic by quite a few people on the planet.

He probably could not even read it.

reply

No. Exactly the opposite, they are essaying to confuse conservatism with fascism. Fascism wasn't anti Islam, Fascism wasn't pro christianity. They also paint the anarchist in a good light.

reply

Depends which version of Fascism you`re talking.Mussolini`s atheistic Fascism was against pretty much all religions.However,Hitler`s Nazism was definitely pro-Christian:

"I believe that I am acting in accordance with the will of the Almighty Creator: by defending myself against the Jew, I am fighting for the work of the Lord.."

"So long as they concern themselves with their religious problems the State does not concern itself with them. But so soon as they attempt by any means whatsoever-- by letters, Encyclica, or otherwise-- to arrogate to themselves rights which belong to the State alone we shall force them back into their proper spiritual, pastoral activity."

-Adolf Hitler, in a speech delivered in Berlin on the May Day festival, 1937 [Baynes]

"Amongst the accusations which are directed against Germany in the so called democracies is the charge that the National Socialist State is hostile to religion. In answer to that charge I should like to make before the German people the following solemn declaration:

1. No one in Germany has in the past been persecuted because of his religious views (Einstellung), nor will anyone in the future be so persecuted....

The Churches are the greatest landed proprietors after the State... Further, the Church in the National Socialist State is in many ways favoured in regard to taxation, and for gifts, legacies, &c., it enjoys immunity from taxation.

It is therefore, to put mildly-- effrontery when especially foreign politicians make bold to speak of hostility to religion in the Third Reich....

I would allow myself only one question: what contributions during the same period have France, England, or the United States made through the State from the public funds?

3. The National Socialist State has not closed a church, nor has it prevented the holding of a religious service, nor has it ever exercised any influence upon the form of a religious service. It has not exercised any pressure upon the doctrine nor on the profession of faith of any of the Confessions. In the National Socialist State anyone is free to seek his blessedness after his own fashion....

There are ten thousands and ten thousands of priests of all the Christian Confessions who perform their ecclesiastical duties just as well as or probably better than the political agitators without ever coming into conflict with the laws of the State....

This State has only once intervened in the internal regulation of the Churches, that is when I myself in 1933 endeavoured to unite the weak and divided Protestant Churches of the different States into one great and powerful Evangelical Church of the Reich. That attempt failed through the opposition of the bishops of some States; it was therefore abandoned. For it is in the last resort not our task to defend or even to strengthen the Evangelical Church through violence against its own representatives....

But on one point it is well that there should be no uncertainty: the German priest as servant of God we shall protect, the priest as political enemy of the German State we shall destroy."

-Adolf Hitler, a speech in the Reichstag on 30 Jan. 1939 [Baynes
]

"I am absolutely convinced of the great power and the deep significance of the Christian religion, and consequently will not permit any other founders of religion (Religionsstifter). Therefore I have turned against Ludendoriff and separated myself from him; therefore I reject Rosenberg's book. That book is written by a Protestant. It is not a party book. It is not written by him as a member of the party. The Protestants can settle matters with him.
My desire is that no confessional conflict arise. I must act correctly to both confessions. I will not tolerate a Kulturkampf.... I stand by my word. I will protect the rights and freedom of the church and will not permit them to be touched. You need have no apprehensions concerning the freedom of the church."


-Hitler [quoted from Helmreich, p.241]

"Secular schools can never be tolerated because such a school has no religious instruction and a general moral instruction without a religious foundation is built on air; consequently, all character training and religion must be derived from faith. from our point of view as representatives of the state, we need believing people. A dark cloud threatens from Poland. We have need of soldiers, believing solders. Believing solders are the most valuable ones. They give their all. Therefore we will maintain the confessional schools in order to train believing people through the schools, but this depends upon having truly believing teachers, not by chance Marxists who do not stand fully by their religious faith, as teachers."

-Hitler, [quoted from Helmreich, p.241]


"Without doubt the chancellor lives in faith in God. He recognizes Christianity as the foundation of Western culture."

-Cardinal Faulhaber [quoted from Helmreich, p.279]


"Except the Lord built the house they labour in vain.... The truth of that text was proved if one looks at the house of which the foundations were laid in 1918 and which since then has been in building.... The world will not help, the people must help itself. Its own strength is the source of life. That strength the Almighty has given us to use; that in it and through it we may wage the battle of our life.... The others in the past years have not had the blessing of the Almighty-- of Him Who in the last resort, whatever man may do, holds in His hands the final decision. Lord God, let us never hesitate or play the coward, let us never forget the duty which we have taken upon us.... We are all proud that through God's powerful aid we have become once more true Germans."

-Adolf Hitler, in a speech in March 1933 [Baynes]

"A folkish state must therefore begin by raising marriage from the level of a continuous defilement of the race, and give it the consecration of an institution which is called upon to produce images of the Lord and not monstrosities halfway between man and ape."

-Adolf Hitler (Mein Kampf)

"...the fall of man in paradise has always been followed by his expulsion."

-Adolf Hitler (Mein Kampf)

reply

It's called paying lip service, politicians do it all the time. Christianity was extremely strong in Germany at this time and since Hitler chose to democratically to climb to power he could not be openly anti christianity. I doubt he was much interested in religion himself though he did admire Islam. The Nazi state persecuted Christian organisations, some christians were sent to concentration camps others purged, the Nazis practised an anti christian policy of forced Euthanasia, concentration camps, disturbing reharking of pre christian paganism and so on. Hitler was a weak dictator and so he had to handle the churches carefully, he tried to bind the churches to his will under a Reich church, but he failed. He banned the scout movement in order that his Youth movement could succeed. don't lap up Nazi propaganda, you wouldn't accept it concerning anything else why accept it in regArds to Christianity?

reply

the jews did ww2 to create *beep* israhell. free palestina death to israhell

reply

you are carzy to think that there is difference between right and left and that they are not both controlled by the same secret societies, both bush and kerry were in the same skull and bones freemasonic club.

reply

Your fascination with Islam has no place here. V is about fascism, whether or not it's religiously motiviated. Even the leader does not believe in Jesus as much as he believes in Fate (the computer).

reply

The right wing nuts hate this movie because if it were for them, there would be a government like the one in the movie.

reply

What is right wing?

reply

Is an ignorant person like you

reply

Thou art amusing. Under 9 are we?

reply