MovieChat Forums > Good Night, and Good Luck. (2005) Discussion > Jazz Singer ONLY Time Movie Comes Alive

Jazz Singer ONLY Time Movie Comes Alive


Every time Dianne Reeves sang, the movie suddenly become alive. personal, warm, emotional and deep. Everyone else 'looked interesting' and I was ready to be interested. The first five minutes, I got right into the film, the period, the cinematography and was 'ready' to be swept into it. Next thing I know the movie is over. That certain 'it' never happened. Something vital is totally missing.

reply

Agree 100 percent. I'd have far preferred 90 minutes of Dianne Reeves in gorgeous black and white.

reply

That certain 'it' never happened. Something vital is totally missing.
I disagree, but I respect your opinion.

...

reply

[deleted]

I would agree that there is some emotional distance in the film. The film centers on the crew while at work at CBS and it isn't revealed much about the personal lives of Murrow, Friendly or any of the others. A few glimpses here and there, but that is about it. Not enough, perhaps, to pull the audience in emotionally.

However, while the characters may not be fully drawn out, the topics in the film concerning McCarthyism, constitutional liberties, and journalism are enough to propel the story forward. There is certainly plenty of drama, although it might be more on the intellectual level.

reply

and it isn't revealed much about the personal lives of Murrow, Friendly or any of the others.
Who cares about that stuff? It has nothing to do with the story the movie is trying to tell. The movie is well acted, but it's not meant to entertain you.

There is certainly plenty of drama, although it might be more on the intellectual level

What's wrong with that? If we want melodrama, there's plenty of that on TV and in lots of bad movies.

reply

and it isn't revealed much about the personal lives of Murrow, Friendly or any of the others.
Who cares about that stuff? It has nothing to do with the story the movie is trying to tell. The movie is well acted, but it's not meant to entertain you.

There is certainly plenty of drama, although it might be more on the intellectual level
What's wrong with that? If we want melodrama, there's plenty of it on TV and in lots of silly movies.

reply

I wanted just a brief peek into Murrow's personal life. He seemed completely drawn in to the news. Did Ed have time for a personal life?

Dianne Reeves was perfect for the role. Maybe elsewhere it tells what singer she was representing?

reply

During the period the film covers, Murrow was married to the former Janet Brewster and had a son, Casey.
May I bone your kipper, Mademoiselle?

reply

The movie just was not interesting!!!!😞Ms. Reeves singing is the best part of the movie!!!!!😌

"Peace and love"

reply