MovieChat Forums > Celebrity Fit Club (2005) Discussion > IT'S NOT FAIR

IT'S NOT FAIR

posted 14 years ago by fishinbuddy2
6 replies | jump to latest

They didnt make the teams even. The heaviest people are all on one team! (THE BLUE TEAM)

Tanisha, Kevin,and the white girl from the Disney Show are all either over 200 pounds or close to it.

IN COMPARISON:

The red team has Shar, Nicole and Bobby- none of whom are badly overweight. In fact, I dont think Bobby & Nicole really belong there in terms of fatness. And Shar isnt very much overweight herself. Jay was, but, he was in better shape than Kevin.

I see how the red team wins so much. They have skinnier people competing.

Think about this; the 4 heaviest people at fit club, (Jay, Kevin, Tanisha, & the white girl from Disney) 3 of them are all on the same team!

It is an unfair match-up this season!

[–] 14 years ago

[deleted]

[–] MermaidsRreal 14 years ago

Remember Tanisha said that in the first episode. She said that there's only one fat person on the opposing team--meaning, Jay. Bobby, Nicole and Shar are technically not overweight or fat at all. Bobby is still skinny, just has a gut, Nicole is just a bit flabby, and Shar just had a little mid section extra meat. On the other team, Sebastian is the only one who's not fat, but he still weighs over 200 lbs. Tanesha, Kevin and Kasey were all obese.

[–] dmoreno27 14 years ago

Kevin is definitely losing that gut (his words is that he looked like he was pregnant)he's really stuck to the food regimen & the challeges as is Jay.

To me...Kevin and Jay really have been losing MOST of their weight!

Donna~

"WAR is OVER-if you want it!!!"...*John Lennon*

[–] marge1986 14 years ago

I thought the same thing. I was thinking, "How can this be fair to match up all the overweight people against the mildly out of shape people?"

Then, when I thought about it, I figured that because they don't only base the scores on the competitions but also on total weight loss. The more overweight people may lose challenges but they will lose more weight (in theory). Whereas, the thinner people may win several challenges but they ultimately may not lose as much weight because there isn't as much weight to be lost.

I could be totally wrong. Just my opinion.

[–] Dynamic_Star88 14 years ago

"How can this be fair to match up all the overweight people against the mildly out of shape people...The more overweight people may lose challenges but they will lose more weight (in theory). Whereas, the thinner people may win several challenges but they ultimately may not lose as much weight because there isn't as much weight to be lost."

I agree that they did put obese people up against people who just needed to lose a couple pounds. I also understand your theory of challenges and weight loss evening out the teams. But I still think they just should have put two slightly over weight people, like Boby and Shar, and two largely overweight people, like Tanisha and Jay, on the same team to even things out completely.

It doesn't cost a thing to smile and you don’t have to pay to laugh! - India Arie

[–] 14 years ago

[deleted]