MovieChat Forums > P.S. I Love You (2007) Discussion > Gerard Butler was cute in this..

Gerard Butler was cute in this..


Usually he just scares me for some reason..

I'm normally not attracted to him or his type but he was kind of attractive in this movie. He smiled a lot and he has a nice mischievous smile 😃. Goes to show you can change your mind about someone.


🐬 ma ink

reply

Really? I found him rather annoying in this (not that Hilary Swank's character was much better). I do generally like him though

reply

He was annoying! 😝 I mean he was so upbeat and energetic all the time... but still kinda cute!

🐬 ma ink

reply

He's definitely good looking but I didn't really find him "attractive" because I didn't like his character. I much preferred Jeffrey Dean Morgan. But overall the film was a bit blah anyway, so maybe it was the film and not Gerard Butler that was disappointing

reply

I always find GB attractive which is odd because his looks change a lot from film to film. I think the actor just has "It." And I also thought he was cute in this. The movie was good but I don't willingly watch Nicholas Sparks-type movies anymore. I've always preferred romantic comedies. Romantic tearjerkers usually do nothing for me. I can't bring myself to watch P.S.ILY again past the first scene - which is the only one in which "Gerry" is alive in real time. All the flashback romantic/cute scenes between Gerry and Holly are just too bittersweet for me.

reply

I prefer romantic comedies too, with happy endings 😃. But there's something about romances with death in the mix that appeal to me, like it puts things in perspective and always makes you aware that time together is the most important thing because u never know when it could all end.

🐬 ma ink

reply