MovieChat Forums > Mary Bryant (2005) Discussion > Cliched, man hating, sexist piffle

Cliched, man hating, sexist piffle


Yet another program where the females are as pure as the driven snow, who only 'go wrong' to feed themselves or their their children (q 'i'm only doing this for the children look, when she starts to prostitute herself'). Fighting against the evil that is man!

Throw in one token 'good guy' to make it look good, and there you have it!

Oh! and apparently all men are rapist as well!!

Dyslexic, I live with it, you get over it!

reply

I thought the 'token' good guy was just to show the stark difference between him and all the other men there, though I guess that does show them all as 'bad'... but maybe it's like he says 'they're all thieves', maybe that's the point, they ARE all criminals, kind of... I was going to write something else but I forgot. I will edit this later it is poo.

But yeah, it did kind of show all men as rapists, but more how desperate they got because they 'weren't getting any'... oh I don't know. lol

---------------------------------
No no no!! Stop slashing things!!

reply


Glad you notice it, and woman don't get desperate.??????


Dyslexic, I live with it, you get over it!

reply

Yeah, but it's slightly more difficult for a woman to rape a man isn't it? LOL that was me arguing on your side, the fact they they're only showing the men as animals and the women as these poor oppressed people.

---------------------------------
No no no!! Stop slashing things!!

reply

Yes I know you where messynessie - sorry if you had the wrong impression.

Dyslexic, I live with it, you get over it!

reply

well actually it was based on a true story and a book

reply

It is. i just learned Australian history aa a topic in my history class (i am still at high school) and even the history books mention something of the countless rapes and sexual harrasment in what purely was a society based on what men thought was right.

reply

My bf got very upset about this at first too. Then he saw that both Will and even Clarke had good points. People have to remember, this was a patriarchal society. x

reply

What the heck do you think happened when the females and males were mixed? You think they just held hands? No, I'm not condemning all men as rapists because thats ignorant, but I am saying that you are being naive in thinking men did not do this sort of thing. It was a testosterone-fuelled society, after all.

reply

Besides, there were heaps of 'good guys'! Will, Sam, Martin, Thomas... and even Clarke, really.

reply

Also at the time the perception of the women on board the ship was that they were all whores and thieves, also the men believed they were just there to satisfy there sexual needs, and as breeders--which technically they were. Not all of the men took part, which, although it isn't mentioned, can be seen in the many decent male characters. But the women were so outnumbered by the men 1-5 that it didn't need all the men to over-power most of the women.

reply

You think this stuff didn't happen? That was such a horrific scene, the massive rape in the colony.

And it's not man hating, back then society was dominated by men and as such women were demeaned, it's not critising men, it's just showing some of the horrific things that have happened.

GG

reply

It's based on a true story.

reply