[deleted]


[deleted]


While he had some effeminate mannerisms, he wasn't a homosexual. The two are not one-and-the-same and we've all known effeminate guys who weren't homosexual. I knew a couple in the Marines. The proof is in the pudding: In the film Timothy had a GIRLfriend, not a boyfriend; and they were close enough that she willingly lived & died with him.

As such, your post is tantamount to speculative slander.

reply

If you explore the net, both newsworthy reviews and psychological hypotheses of Treadwell, you'll see that I'm not in the minority in coming to this conclusion. Do you always accuse people of slander when their opinions or reviews aren't the same as yours? Being in a heterosexual relationship isn't evidence of one's sexual preferences; Rock Hudson, Anthony Perkins, and the list goes on. It's not an insult but an observation.

reply

If you explore the net, both newsworthy reviews and psychological hypotheses of Treadwell, you'll see that I'm not in the minority in coming to this conclusion.


This fallacious argument suggests that something is automatically true if enough people believe it and that something is automatically false if a minority believes it.

Slander is to say something untrue of a person; usually something the person wouldn't like. Whether Treadwell was a little foppish or not is irrelevant. The facts show that he preferred women in sexual/romantic relationships; if not, there would've been a DUDE in his tent when he got eaten alive.

reply

Let's continue tto pretend bi-sexuality isn't a thing and call others names. *facepalm*

reply

I'm just going by the data presented in the film: Treadwell had a woman in his tent, not a dude, nor a woman and a dude. That tells me he was heterosexual despite some effeminate mannerisms. I was in the Marines years ago and one of the guys in one platoon had effeminate traits, but when we went into town to party he always picked up a babe. So foppish characteristics alone can be deceiving.

Now don't be heterophobic in your response or I'll have no recourse but to call you a heterophobe.

reply

Having a GIRLfriend doesn't mean anything one way or the other.

reply

It obviously reveals he preferred women in sexual/romantic relationships and actually practiced this preference.

reply

No it doesn't, and we have no idea what he practiced.
You obviously don't know much about gays?


The reality is, he obviously preferred bears.

reply

Notice that I gave a context to my statement "It obviously reveals he preferred women": in sexual/romantic relationships. So, sure, he preferred bears as far as viewing animals goes, but in sexual/romantic relations he obviously preferred women. Again, it was a WOMAN sharing his tent, not a dude (nor a bear). What is it about this that eludes you?

And, by the way, I never said I had insight to EVERYTHING about Treadwell and his potential psychoses. I'm simply going by the evidence IN THE FILM.

reply

So your proposition suggests that Timothy would not have been eaten by a bear, and that the bear itself would have lived, if only Timothy would have engaged in anal sex with men?

That's an interesting line of thought - right up there with the belief of many in Africa that sex with an uninfected female infant can cure an adult sufferer of AIDS.

Let me guess, you majored in Sociology?

reply

If that's honestly what you got from my comment, the error in thinking is yours genius. Nope, psychology and English.

reply

Oh, I don't know, Sociology's pretty damn close for a cold reading online. I'll take 3/4 credit on that one. The English, however, that's just special. B.A.'s for everyone, Bernie's picking-up the tab!

:o)

reply

Let me guess: You didn't major in anything.

If that is what you gathered from his post, you really are some dense motherfucker.

reply