MovieChat Forums > August Rush (2007) Discussion > Parent's Love Story Pathetic & Unrealist...

Parent's Love Story Pathetic & Unrealistic


I find August's parents love story highly ridiculous. They meet, talk for less than 2 and a half minutes, all this awkward totally undeserved stares at each other, then they're kissing and having sex.
The mother shows initially that her character/personality isn't the promiscuous initiator. She's seen to be a wallflower, somewhat shy and reserved, even preferring to avoid parties and be alone.
I realise they obviously needed the two to get together for the eventual storyline, but geez they could've come up with much better than that. It's just stupid. They weren't even trying

reply

Did you not see the description on the front page?...a fairy tale...which always has a HEA my favorite go to movie when I need uplifting...does it every time..

reply

A fairy tale deserving of the accolades people have heaped onto an undeserving film and one that I loved was "Ever After: A Cinderella Story (1998)_ starring Drew Barrymore as the title character. Set in Renaissance-era France, in this version, there is no fairy godmother, instead, the film takes a more historical approach with "Danielle" (Cinderella's name in this version) friending Leonardo Da Vinci, having a kind step-sister (and a mean one as well) and raised to be independent by her father, who also passed on his love of books to her. Unlike "August Rush", this film shows real emotions and why they exist. Why Danielle risks her life to save the husband of a family servant from being shipped to the Americas, why she works so hard alongside the other servants (which for all intents and purposes she is considered one by her "family") to keep up the home she grew up in that now belongs to her abusive step-mother and so on. Drew Barrymore is great in the role of Danielle as is Anjelica Huston in the role as her stepmother who, toward the end, when asked by Danielle if she loved her father answered "I never knew him". When told that all she (Danielle) ever wanted was a mother's love and asked why she was never shown even the smallest amount of kindness was answered with " This, not August Rush, is a great fairytale.

reply

Agreed. In the entire minute Lyla was pregnant, she didn't think of looking for Connelly (John?)? Since she planned on keeping it, she obviously didn't sign any papers giving up her child so how did her father get away with the "baby died" lie? Was she in a coma when she gave birth? Didn't ANYONE think to ask her (she was over 18) if she was ready to see the baby, regardless of whether she was giving it up (again, since she wasn't I doubt that her father could get away with the subterfuge he perpetrated)? I could go on and on, but wasting any more time on this wanna-be Hallmark special from the '80's with wasted actors who must have been really broke to accept acting in this drivel. Didn't Jonathan Rhys-Meyers do Julie Taymor's "Titus" around this time? You think that he'd know better. Although I disliked The Tudors due to the numerous historical inaccuracies, he was a great Henry VIII and of course I loved "Titus" and thought he was quite good in that and his scenes with the brilliant Harry Lennox as the villainous Moor were great. What were these actors thinking?

reply