MovieChat Forums > Superhero Movie (2008) Discussion > Message to the writers about Stephen Haw...

Message to the writers about Stephen Hawking.


Besides the horrible quality of the movie, I also minded all the Stephen Hawking jokes. He has what is called a amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. It was diagnosed while he was still in Cambridge, and he's been suffering horribly for many long years, gradually losing his moving capabilities over the years.
And the fact that he cannot speak fluidly over his voice synth only point towards your ignorance judging by how you represented him in your film. His speeches are prepared in advance, he is using only his cheek to type the information in and it takes about 7 minutes for him to type an answer to a regular question in a conversation for Christ's sake!
And the fact that such illness has affected such a brilliant and good man is a terrible tragedy to put it mildly.
You (writers and directors) are disgusting and horrible persons. The world would be a better place without those like you. Even tho you might feel superior over that man because you're not tied in a chair, his intelligence dwarfs yours on an astronomical scale. Compared to him, you are simply retarded. If I ever met you in person, I'd spit in your face (or better yet, not, people like you are not worthy of me wasting my bodily fluids to show a gesture!).

reply

Yeah, I really don't see what he did to deserve this.




reply

If Stephen Hawking can't laugh at himself (on the inside, he doesn't have to type it) then he can't be that brilliant.
Brilliance is, after all, shown through ones ability to laugh at oneself. So bleh.

I'm delightfully mad!

reply

"Brilliance is, after all, shown through ones ability to laugh at oneself. So bleh."

If so, where's my Nobel Price?

"That was a courtesy flush. I'm not actually done yet"

reply

I do agree that some of it was in poor taste - mainly the silly physical stuff but did you really expect any better from these kinds of films? They have evolved into quite crude films since the grand daddy of them all, "Airplane!" first came out.

I did like it when Hawkins first came out for the science event and all the kids were waiting for his wise words and he starts saying all this bad stuff and shocking them. It was great to see him having some fun after all the documentaries I've watched involving him.

There is a bit where Leslie Nelson pushes him into the background and he bangs into something and flies out of the chair. I think it's a throwback to a similar scene in The Naked Gun.

reply

You DO REALIZE THAT THIS WAS NOT HAWAKINS but an actor, right?!

---------------------------
You don't see things as they are, you see things as we are.

reply

I agree, mostly. Crude and offensive.

http://technewsdaily.blogspot.com

reply

I agree, this is one of the things not to be joked about. At that scene I just wanted to stop watching the movie.

reply

i'm at 26, and i saw hawkings been put in multiple ocasions on comedy, due to whats appears to be its actual condition - head drifted on a wheelchair and talking like a computer, like a brain that talks and don't show up any emotion -
this or every scene made up with that, isnt fun. i would be more impressed with the movie if producers agreed first with hawkings to do this type of scenes.

Life must be cruel for ones while others are wasting their lifes producing *beep* movies.

reply

Well, Stephen Hawking's cameos in The Simpsons and in Family Guy (especially the first one) where clever and good-tasteful, unlike that offensive crap.
I'm in no way a supporter of political correctness, but this one wasn't just funny, and I can see why someone could find it offensive.

DEATH METAL FOREVER!!! I_I I_I I_I
www.myspace.com/clayman666_82

reply

The REAL Stephen Hawking actually appeared in a humorous scene in a Star Trek: The Next Generation episode. So he's not beyond wanting to appear in TV. And if he's in such terrific pain, why did he recently go up in NASA's KC-135A (the Vomit Comet) and do numerous zero-G parabolas? The guy is not such a stuffed shirt as you guys make him out to be. Nothing is more annoying to a handicapped person then to be constantly mothered over and shielded from real life by well-intentioned people.

reply

Don't get me wrong. I feel for Hawking. His condition is absolutely heartbreaking, and he's too brilliant a mind to have to deal with it.

But this is a movie . A spoof movie. A spoof movie clearly written for middle schoolers, most of whom have no idea who Stephen Hawking even is. No, having Hawking's computer making random lewd comments was not funny. But the filmmakers, more likely than not, didn't mean to offend. They were just turned on by the almighty dollar, which apparently, is earned nowadays by creating the crudest, raunchiest comedy you can.

I rather liked Baines. We shared the same bootmaker.

reply

[deleted]

Glad to see that others were as put off by these cheap efforts for laughs as I was. This ain't Shakespeare, and there were some good laughs along the way. But nothing was added by this tacky and tasteless portrayal.

I appreciated the earlier poster who made a point of having no problem with the politically incorrect humor but did have a problem with this. I feel the exact same way. Seems like it would've made more sense for the writers/director to cut out this material, if for no other reason, then to eliminate the uneasiness audiences might have about such remarkable disrespect.

I've never met the man, and of course none of these reactions come by way of pity. Just embarrassed that this is what talented people who come together for a project splay out for the world to see, as if proud of their own cleverness.

It's really not all that different from how the carnival barkers of the nineteenth century treated Joseph Merrick (aka The Elephant Man.)

And I'd guess that for about six out of ten people who see this movie, the Hawking material will be the most lasting impression. And certainly not a positive one.

Six out of ten? Maybe I'm being naive.

reply

[deleted]

----"We need to be politically incorrect."----

I don't think we 'need' to be politically incorrect. Having the first amendment right to do something doesn't expunge people for pointless creative decisions that, IMO, failed to approach the horizon of being funny.


----"Just because Stephen Hawking is a cripple doesn't mean that he shouldn't be a target for humor. "----

You're right. But they missed the target, and ultimately came off like thoughtless thirteen year-olds.

reply

I thought some the jokes were funny... I mean, was Hawking really made fun of in the movie?

(watched only some of it)

reply

was Hawking really made fun of in the movie?

(watched only some of it)


you've come to the right thread then

reply

Just watched this yesterday. I thought almost every scene portraying Stephen Hawking was hilarious.

I think even he would find it funny, and I would only consider second-guessing myself if Hawking himself were offended.

"I want you to be nice... until it's time to not be nice." Patrick Swayze 1952-2009

reply

"You, Whiteguy with the dreads. you know what i'm talking about"

i always love that one

http://twitter.com/chappy422

reply

I agree with the OP. Hawking is a thoroughly undeserving target, particularly in how the jokes made him suicidal. How the pathetic and cruel minds of the writers came up with the scene confuses me, but says a good deal about their lack of humanity.

It was a despicable portrayal of a man who has struggled tirelessly to beat a devastating illness, and influenced far more lives than the hacks who churn out these stupid little films could ever hope. They will continue to produce disposable rubbish while Hawking's legacy will last for hundreds of years.

The film shows every sign that there was very deliberate malice of forethought involved, just to generate laughs. It's a sad trend that comedy goes for shock value, rather than genuine wit. I'd compare it with Family Guy, and its malicious attacks on Michael J Fox and other people who have suffered. I often bring this up with people who enjoy family Guy, and they happily try to defend the indefensible; cheap laughs at the expense of someone's suffering.

Contempt is all this kind of comedy deserves.

reply