MovieChat Forums > Sorry, Haters (2006) Discussion > a couple of questions...

a couple of questions...


I'm sure I missed it somewhere along the way but I have to ask, was that guy her ex husband at all?...the one with Sandra Oh, who was that child on the guys's schoulders in the picture?? and what about a daughter she spoke of, the kid on that guy's shoulders in the picture does not look like Sandra Oh's daughter who they showed...so are we to assume Phoebe had no ex husband or daughter at all, she fabricated the whole thing??
Also, one more question, what were those two bags in the box Phoebe got?

reply

I took it to be explosive (as I sat and pondered the ending) C4 ? Does it come in dark green ? But as she handled it with gloves and a face mask....and slipped a small packet into his inside pocket....I am pretty sure it was explosive. One of the best performances of a disturbed woman I have ever witnessed. And I think she fabricated the whole thing.

reply

When she met Ashade, she claimed she was Philly (Sandra Oh)and that Philly's life was her own life. Philly's husband met Phoebe first. Apparently Phoebe liked him, but he married Philly, apparently never knowing how Phoebe felt? The fact that he met Phoebe first was revealed during the lunch with the prospective date for Phoebe. It sounded to me as though Phoebe spun that story, perhaps half believing it, out of her jealousy. The name of her supposed child turned out to be the dog's name. Except, at the very end, she called the dog "Jealousy." I have to say I was more blown away by the end scene with the dog than the earlier action, which was somewhat predictable from things she had said in the early scenes.

reply

After she threw the dog, the scene froze on her with credits on the screen that made it look like a music video. It was the same situation as the music video playing in her offices, including the same model of truck. If she had anything to do with the production of that other video, then the little dog in that one may have met the same fate.

reply

The second time i saw it, noticed the child looked half asian and phobe didn't seem to have any emotional connection with it on the sidewalk, so doubtful it could have been hers.

The guy playing the husband looks familiar but i couldn't find him listed in the cast. He had lot of lines but got less credit than the security guard, who had no lines and just played dumb while watching his dvd player. And whats fred durst getting credit for? (Did the producer like limp roles for biscuits?)

I didn't know you could receive c4 explosives in the mail, like that.
She must have been an explosives expert to have prepared a compact detonating device that could fit in a pocket and have enough confidence that it would go off and prevent having an angry muslim coming after her.
It was also astute of hamid to know it was a bomb in his pocket and warn off the innocent civilians before it blew up.

(Not enough time to list so many questions the movie raised)

reply

I had the same question about Phoebe's boss, her husband and child. Admittedly I have been unable to catch this very fascinating movie from the start, despite frequent airings on IFC. The earliets point at which I began viewing was when Phoebe was up in Ashade's apartment speaking with his sister-in-law, etc. Phoebe mentions a former artist husband and daughter "stolen" away by a tutor(?) hired to teach the daughter Mandarin. Then (I think) she pulled out the photo showing her boss and family. I realized later that her story of a former husband/daughter most likely had to be a fabrication, with Phoebe using the photo as a misrepresentaion. Otherwise, are we to believe that Phoebe and company would be so amicable and accepting of each other? I hardly think so. However, Phoebe's abandonment fantasy is based on some fact: we find out her boss' husband is actually an artist, and that he and Phoebe did know each other early on...a detail substantiated by her boss during the lunch scene. As far as the bags in the box, I believe they were a type of explosive. What I found so frustrating was that so many pivotal and crucial details are lost on me because some of the critical dialog is so hushed or mumbled; I need to buy the DVD just so I can view the subtitles! I also haven't figured out what was on her cell phone, or what the kid-on-guy's-shoulder photo is about.

reply

It was a complete lie. The two women had been close friends. They knew the man because he took a class with Pheobe, who was infatuated with him, but was never his girlfriend. He and Philly fell in love, got married, had a kid, moved to the suburbs. Pheobe was jealous and enjoyed telling her distortion of the story to someone who couldn't know better.

reply