MovieChat Forums > Relative Strangers (2006) Discussion > How many similariteis can you spot betwe...

How many similariteis can you spot between....


...this movie and "What About Bob"? http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0103241/

Some days you eat the bar,some days the bar eats you
http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=11738345

reply

You know, it's funny, I was just watching this film and thought to myself that it is "What About Bob?" -- except badly done and with less-interesting and less-sympathetic characters.

reply


I saw it was on Comedy Central yesterday and was wondering if anyone would respond to my post

Some days you eat the bar,some days the bar eats you
http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=11738345

reply

I love this film and don't see all that many similarities to What About Bob, other than the fact he's a psychologist with a self help book. The characters and situations are way different.

reply

Both movies include;


A)Both protagonists are
1)Psychiatrists
2)self absorbed,
3)wrote self help books,
4)are humiliated on national TV while pushing their books by the antagonists
5)driven to a mental breakdown
6)believed irrational by family members concerning their treatment of the antagonists

B)Both Antagonists are
1)thrust upon the main character
2)are socially inept and unaware of their destructive behavior concerning the main character
3)maliciously assisted by a secondary character to remain in the life of the main character as to cause chaos

In the end of the film both protagonist and antagonist are inseparable(for good or bad)from each others lives.


These are a few off the top of my head similarities. I haven't actually done a side by side study.
Am I putting forth that each movie does not have it's own nuances? No. Nor am I saying the idea was plagiarized. But the similarities are there.


Some days you eat the bar,some days the bar eats you
http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=11738345

reply

It reminds me of a poorer version of "Mr. Woodcock". But "What about Bob" came to my mind as well, especially since it's another movie about a psychiatrist going nuts because of people invading their lives.

reply