MovieChat Forums > Mickey's Twice Upon a Christmas (2004) Discussion > THIS IS JUNK COMPARED TO MICKEY'S ONCE U...

THIS IS JUNK COMPARED TO MICKEY'S ONCE UPON A CHRISTMAS!


I CAN'T BELIEVE PEOPLE ACTUALLY THINK THIS IS WAY BETTER THAN IT'S PREDECESSOR.I MEAN MICKEY'S ONCE UPON A CHRISTMAS HAD WAY MORE HEART AND LAUGHTER TO IT,AND IT ACTUALLY PUT YOU IN THE CHRISTMAS SPIRIT,UNLIKE THIS ONE.THE ONLY DECENT ONE OUT OF ALL OF THESE WAS DONALD'S GIFT.ANYONE ELSE AGREE?

reply

Nope. Please stop yelling.

reply

I have only seen the first one but I record it every christmas when it is on TV and force my family to watch it with me like 100 times! I have seen short clips from Twice but the fact it is digital is almost gross to me! I LOVED the original and the drawings, it makes it much more...timeless... at least to me...

R.I.P Steve Irwin, I didn't know you but I felt like you were my best friend...I'll miss you.

reply

After seeing both of the Mickey's christmas specials, I found Twice Upon a christmas to be much more fun, more enjoyable, and more in the true spirit of Christmas then the 1st one.

It had better animation, better stories, great music, and at the end I felt all warm and fuzzy. The first one i found the stories were too long, too dragged out, and no musical segments.

i'd give the 2nd one a 10 and the 1st one a 7.

reply

Yeah, I prefer 2D, but Twice upon a Christmas is much better...

reply

Watched this one after Once Upon A Christmas with my godson,and I must say this was very weak.The animation was actually nice in Once Upon A Christmas.And the stories were better than on here.The only one that was okay was the one with Donald Duck.

reply

No. Mickey's Once Upon a Christmas in my opinion was better, but this was a beautiful and heart-warming follow up, that was beautifully animated, had some very nice music and the stories were interesting.





"Life after death is as improbable as sex after marriage"- Madeline Kahn(CLUE, 1985)

reply

I think both are beautiful movies. I do prefer the first one, though.

reply