MovieChat Forums > Joyeux Noël (2005) Discussion > Another World War 'unofficial mini-truce...

Another World War 'unofficial mini-truce' movie... Help?


I remember seeing another movie about soldiers who lay down their arms in the midst of war, both sides (or were there more than two?) just hanging out together, playing games (perhaps soccer as well), eating together, forming friendships, dancing... But this movie took place in Italy, in the Summer. I liked it better than "Joyeux Noël", but I don't remember the title, and I haven't succeeded in finding the movie by googling keywords.

Does anybody know of it?

reply

[deleted]

No; sorry. But thank you for taking the trouble to reply. :)

reply


It was first shown as an unsolved mystery episode. Watch it here: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0338434/ its good. Then Made into a movie called silent night:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0338434/

reply

Thank you; I will watch that one. It still isn't the one I was thinking of, though.

reply

Could it " A midnight clear"?

let's go and say a prayer for a boy who couldn't run as fast as I could

reply

Thank you for chiming in; I appreciate it. That can't be it, though, as the one I'm looking for takes places in the summer.

reply

Could it be " A midnight clear"?

let's go and say a prayer for a boy who couldn't run as fast as I could

reply

It could be "Mi mejor enemigo" http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0410316/

http://bit.ly/9XcDAU

reply

Hmmmm... Maybe, although it would mean that I remember it rather incorrectly. I'm pretty sure it was WW2... but I'll check it out. Thank you!

reply

This is the kind of thing that might be found quickly on the "News & Community" section's Board named "I Need to Know". Finding movie title's in minutes from a description such as yours.

reply

Thank you! It's very kind of you to take the time to tell me. :)

reply

Oh! Wait. I got caught up in the 'truce' thing, but this does sound familiar to me. How about you?

We would see this movie on television in the late 1960s. It was set in World War Two, and I remember a British officer was given the task (punishment?) of taking custody of a group of Italian POWs. There was no truce. There were three or four memorable scenes.

1) There was something like a basket, but shaped like a ball. Perhaps the Italians had to clean up a beach or field or something. Somehow the ball/basket dropped, and one of the prisoners bounced it up with his knee, like a soccer ball. Everyone stopped, British and Italian, as they tried the 'ball' again, and then they wildly started a soccer match. (Very amusing, not as a joke, but because the audience recognizes the tendency for Europeans to drop whatever they're doing to play soccer.)

2) There was a long sequence in which the British officer decides a latrine is needed, and orders the Italian officer to have his men dig the hole and build the latrine. The prisoner officer doesn't want to do it, he feels like this is insultingly beneath the Italians. I won't ever forget how he is almost dripping tears as he yells "I will NOT BUILD a LAT-RIN-A!"

3) But, because of some deal making, or wheeling and dealing, the Italians do build a fine latrine. The British officer walks over, somewhat triumphantly, and with great dignity, and inspects it, and before he can pronounce it to be satisfactory, he (as always, with great dignity) slowly sits down, out of sight, to give it a test run.

4) By the end of the film, they all are friends and have mutual respect. The Italian POWs are heading to a train to be transported somewhere, and the Italian officer turns and smiles at the British officer who smiles back. The Italian runs to the train and disappears as the film ends.

Is this to what you were referring? (Sorry to not have a name -- I did a search based on the officer's resemblance to David Niven, but couldn't get anything yet.)

reply

Is this it? http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0054678 "The Best of Enemies" (1961)

reply

I think you may be thinking of "A Midnight Clear." I believe that was set during WWII. One of my favorite films.

reply

"Oh! What a Lovely War"

MANY years ago, during a leave in 1970 between tours in Viet Nam, I saw the wonderful Richard Attenborough film realization of Joan Littlewood's "Oh! What a Lovely War," which was a satirical musical review on World War I from the early Sixties.

I just took a look at my DVD to ascertain that there is indeed a rather moving Christmas truce scene at about 53 (or so) minutes into the film.

Is that any help?

reply

Thank you so much (belatedly). That was very kind of you. I'm pretty sure it was neither a musical or satirical, but I'll look into it. Thanks again. :)

reply

This happened in "What did you do in the war daddy". It was a comedy, a very good one.

reply

Mediterraneo:

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0102426/

I dislike this movie. Joyeux Noel was better.

But it I think it's what you're referencing. The soldiers were Italian & occupying Greek territory on German orders. The Greeks initially feared them as invaders but the Italians really didn't care about the war. It wasn't so much a truce as occupiers interacting with the occupied civilians.

reply