MovieChat Forums > The X Factor (2004) Discussion > X Factor USA is much more fun!

X Factor USA is much more fun!


Started watching the US version and it's much better and a lot more fun. No tedious double auditions it's better produced and Simon trying to deal with three women is very funny.

reply

[deleted]

I agree US X Factor is better, but The Voice USA is so much better than The X Factor.

reply

No, XF USA is crap, as is any version of The Voice.






Nicholas Bloody Parsons

reply

No it's not, The Voice has some talent ..... IMO :)

reply

[deleted]

I had a good laugh at your comment :-

"I don't understand people who watch both The Voice and The X Factor. How do you not get bored of dull singing competitions? They're all mediocre singers."

What I cannot understand is why when you clearly don't care for the programme you come on here to read about it, and you have made 28 posts about it? Don't you get bored? :)

reply

[deleted]

Seriously Uncle_Jack, wouldn't you rather talk to the people you have come to know about something that you have a positive comment to make? Every one is entitled to their opinion of course, I was merely agreeing with the OP about The X Factor US being more fun, and adding that I thought The Voice US was better....IMO. I no longer watch the UK or US X Factor because I don't like the new format. In my opinion the singers on The Voice US are not mediocre, so I look forward to watching it. If I didn't like it or was bored I wouldn't watch it nor would I bother to come on here to criticise the opinion of someone else. If everyone liked the same things life could get dull :)

reply

[deleted]

Oops sorry I must've misunderstood your comment. Thought you were questioning my 'boredom levels'.

reply

I'm from the US & I actually prefer the UK contestants to our own. Love Tamera & Rough Copy!

The only contestants in the US I like are Josh Levi, Roxxy Montana & Carlito Olivero.

reply

I completely agree with simonrosenbaum. I normally watch the UK and USA one but I have stopped watching the UK one at the early audition stage this year and won't be returning until all 4 judges are replaced.

Gary Barlow - THE DULLEST PERSON ON TV. At least Simon Cowell injects humour into his criticisms but Barlow is the most boring person on TV. SACK HIM.

Sharon - THIS WOMAN IS THE MOST ANNOYING WOMAN ON TV. SACK HER.

Louis - The plays the daft Irishman stereotype quite well.

Nicole - IS SHE ON DRUGS? She doesn't critique she just spouts a load of nonsense and at the same time she tries to be ghetto and has obviously been watching Kelly Rowland far too much. Nicole - YOU ARE NOT BLACK! She has no black in her so why does she pretend to act "black"? SACK HER

At least 3 of the judges need to be replaced or the X Factor UK will be cancelled.


The US version is far superior with Demi Levato and Simon Cowell.

reply

Were you a fan of PCD before Nicole went solo? Nicole has always had a big personality and is not trying to 'act black.' No such thing 'acting black' by the way ... it's a complete prejudiced notion. Black people aren't a monolith and, thus, don't all behave the same way. Perhaps she's influenced by urban culture.

reply

I am now watching the uk live shows and I agree the judges are really letting it down this year. Mrs O and Nicole are both as mad as hatters, Louie cant really critique to save his life "Your like a little Johnny Depp" he said the other night and even Dermot thought he'd lost the plot. Thank goodness him and Gary have said it's their last one.
We need four new judges next year who know what their talking about can make thoughtful and constructive comments don't talk in cliches and aren't on they way to the funny farm!

reply

X Factor USA is much more fun!
That's a bit like saying "my turd is shinier than your turd"!

Welcome to the IMDB drinking game!

reply

I watch both. Although US judges were more fun during the auditions, as the 3 girls were bullying Simon, but UK has better singers this year. I don't think US got a singer good singer on x-factor this year. Don't even know who to root for.

---
I want my freedom FROM religion!

reply

too bad all the singers are garbage. this show is fake wank as *beep*

reply