scary ? creepy ? comparing with the descent

Well... I did a couple times during the second floor visits... especially when "she" appears. It was rather a "creepy atmosphere/guess who's who movie" rather than a "NOW JUMP" film.

That and of course the fact that this one respected the viewer's intelligence and did not create a killer who had developed a super-hearing skill with no nostrills... how could those creatures be blind and not smell the girls in front of them... no clue.

I liked this one a lot. Sad thing Calista is taking such a long hiatus and Jaume is so underrated. Really good filmmaking, good story and good acting.

I've seen both movies.
I think the Descent was better, more action.. And I like the ending.

But Fragile is also scary.. If you believe in ghosts.

I don't think you can compare these two movies...they're completely different, aren't they? It's like comparing Scream an Ju-On, the only similarity is that people die and the word "horror"


Suicide is the most sincere form of self-criticism.

I dont think that The Decent is a good movie to make a comparison with.
But this movie deffinately makes an excellent double feature with 'Session 9'.

This isn't really scary, just a little creepy and atmospheric in places. The Decent is more effective but a lot less subtle with it.

"In the immortal words of The Doors... 'the time to hesitate is through'"

The Descent is a waaaaaaay better movie. I didn't jump once in Fragiles, it was more of a supposed-to-be-scary-ghost-movie. :S

Well this was more of a fairytale thing and certainly not a masterpiece like Descent. It had it´s moments but I was sort of disappointed with the kindness of the whole thing, Descent was far more cruel and nasty. Still, it is worth a watch especially if you enjoy films like The others etc.

you can't compare the two at all. Descent was more of a survival horror/action movie, while this was a classic ghost story. Both had scary parts, both were well made. Foreign horror has really gotten better then American.