MovieChat Forums > El perro (2004) Discussion > What's with the watches?

What's with the watches?


Just loved this movie. Nearly cried as my dog was snoring next to me. Was just wondering: what's with the giant watches on the walls. Obviously, some kind of symbolism.....something like your time will come ???

reply

[deleted]

According to the dvd extras the watch clocks are just typical of clocks used in that part of Argentina - the production designer (i think) found them.

reply

Well, I love a good symbol as the next reviewer, and one could also argue that you can make a symbol out of anything, but all that's needed to understand the knives is cultural context. Every Argentine home has one beautiful knife or "facón", even the most urban among us. Facones are useful pieces of art.

reply

I came to think it might have something to do with the line "Time is the only thing I have plenty of". Maybe the appearance of watches and clocks was a painful reminder of the amount of time but the lack of money.

Seigneur ne leur pardonnez, pas car ils savent ce qu'ils font tagline in Sheitan

reply

totally agree MadameCassel - think you have it on the nose right there. For some reason that line just stuck in my head - it was so brilliantly delivered, and that scene where he delivers it really goes a long way to revealing everything about his situation and the type of guy that he is. Down on his luck, yet always kind enough to go out of his way, even for people that he doesn't know. Such a totally charming and beautiful movie, I loved it.

reply

I would strongly suggest that the clocks symbolise the oblivion in the Argentinean Patagonia. Just to put this into context, the Patagonia has always been regarded as a "forgetten" part of Argentina, due to its geographical location, lanscape and small population. During the Malvinas war, many young men from the Patagonia died for their country and were soon forgotten by the rest of the Argentinean society. Going a bit further back in time, many folk songs and stories talk about solitude and timelessness of the Patagonia. This is particularly well conveyed in the stories of the Argentinean gauchos whose narrative often has as a central point the theme of solitude and oblivion. Going back to the symbolism of the clocks, basically, I would say that the most clear interpretation is that the director wants to stress that time is existant but irrelevant in this part of the world, somewhat forgotten by the rest of Argentina and the world. Time passes by, and so it goes, but everything else is the same, and it is as if everything passes by in a vaccum. Just one final thought, if a place on earth is forgotten, is time of any importance to the people there?

reply

I don't see any relation between La Patagonia and Malvinas conflict. Most of the soldiers that died in the war were from the north part of Argentina (Corrientes, Misiones, Chaco). The movie is great. The dog is great. And the actors are great (even if they aren't). Sorin is a genius, with simple stories he makes great films.

reply

Time passes by, and so it goes, but everything else is the same, and it is as if everything passes by in a vaccum. Just one final thought, if a place on earth is forgotten, is time of any importance to the people there?
And yet time is enshrined in large, glossy watches and clocks.

I wondered if Juan saw the watches/clocks as a symbol of success.
what a season
to be beautiful
without a reason

reply

He was a free spirit and I think he felt hemmed in by clocks and watches. He seemed to have no conception of time himself. He ate at any time that suited him (when he arrived back at the house with the dog the day he 'inherited' him, or when he bought a whole cake after he put the dog on the bus with Walter), and other people used time to bully him (the man at the labour dept, Walter with his 3am wakeup call). He was happiest operating outside of time. At the end of the movie, he is with his fellow free spirits - there's no agenda, just driving.

reply