MovieChat Forums > Veer-Zaara (2004) Discussion > TITANIC or VEER-ZAARA?

TITANIC or VEER-ZAARA?

posted 17 years ago by DreamyGirl247
22 replies | jump to latest

So which love story does everyone think was the better love story?

Personally I think that TITANIC was the best film to have ever been made in Hollywood and VEER-ZAARA is without a doubt one of the all time best films ever made in history as well, and certainly one of the top two best Bollywood films I have ever seen, right up there with DEVDAS.

So which one do you guys think was the better, more touching or unforgettable love story? And please in order to post here you have to be a fan of either VEER-ZAARA OR TITANIC or both. Don't just come on here and make rude comments like: "they both sucked" or "neither" or whatever! If you can't stand either film or both then don't bother posting here and pissing people off. That being said what does everyone say?

TITANIC

or

VEER-ZAARA

"I will never let go, Jack. I'll never let go."-Rose DeWitt Bukater From TITANIC (1997)

[–] tennisman45 17 years ago

IMHO, Titanic never deserved the accolades it recieved. Veer-Zaara all the way.

[–] DreamyGirl247 17 years ago

Hmm interesting very interesting. Okay so far we've got one vote for VEER-ZAARA!

"I will never let go, Jack. I'll never let go."-Rose DeWitt Bukater From TITANIC (1997)

[–] ChocolateIsMyDrug 17 years ago

Veer-Zaara.

[–] 17 years ago

[deleted]

[–] DreamyGirl247 17 years ago

Wow, uh oh hello all TITANIC fans so far VEER-ZAARA is in the lead, let's make it a bit more interesting, the first film to get 100 votes wins the IMDb.com Best Love Story of All Time Award, lol sorry for the corniness but the first movie to get 100 votes is the winner.

"I will never let go, Jack. I'll never let go."-Rose DeWitt Bukater From TITANIC (1997)

[–] CantShineAsBrightAsYou 17 years ago

I enjoyed both very much, I love foreign films.

I don't know which one is "better"; they both had their own pro's and con's. I thought Veer-Zaara was a bit unrealistic in places, but it wasn't "corny" as some parts of Titanic.

You don't have to count this as a vote, because technically I'm not picking one over the other, haha, but I just wanted to put this out there.

Veer-Zaara was an excellent movie, by the way.

You can't have roots and wings.

[–] Val-El 17 years ago

Titanic had a bad ending. Vote is for V-Z

[–] Zacef 17 years ago

Lets not go to far - Veer Zaara wasnt that great. To some, including me, it was quite offensive and had a really stupid ending although if you want to compare Titanic to Devdas then i completly agree.

i would still pick Titanic but Devdas is on the same level as they were both beautifully made and perfect from start to finish. And both films were tragic love stories which made you cry like a baby at the end (God why do they do that) and had really beautiful music to go with the film. But i still have to pick Titanic because it was my the first ever favourite movie although arguably Devdas was my first every favourite indian movie...

[–] DreamyGirl247 17 years ago

I don't see anything about the ending of VEER-ZAARA as stupid at all.

SEXY LADY ON THE FLOOR, KEEP YOU COMING BACK FOR MORE.

[–] Zacef 17 years ago

you have to be pakistani and muslim in order to understand why i found it pathetic...

[–] DreamyGirl247 17 years ago

Well actually my mother is Muslim because she is Turkish and she loved it so did a lot of Muslim people, I don't think you should take it personally and it doesn't make it a bad film at all.

SEXY LADY ON THE FLOOR, KEEP YOU COMING BACK FOR MORE.

[–] ChocolateIsMyDrug 17 years ago

What did you find offensive about V-Z? Can you please explain?

[–] Nancyforjoy 17 years ago

you have to be more open minded. You expect others to accept your opinions

[–] AfgJasmine 17 years ago

I'm Muslim and i didnt find Veer-Zaara offenisve at all.

And i love both Titanic and Veer-Zaara. But i am gonna go with Veer-Zaara because i loved the music and songs in it :)

[–] 17 years ago

[deleted]

[–] kingkhan 16 years ago

Veer-Zaara

[–] Serpico1988 16 years ago

Both films are amazing.

However neither of these two come anywhere near the level of Casablanca.

[–] mekeItellu 16 years ago

Veer-Zaara of course!! Americans can't touch this scene with SRK and Preity Zinta.

It's on You Tube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V49RjPezN-o

[–] Sahil_Madan 15 years ago

Dude, why are you compering SRK and Preity Zinta? Just that you did compare them to hollywood shows that hollywood are better (obviously). This movie was boring! I already knew what will be the story of the film and how it will be ending. It had two options. One was that SRK will get Preity Zinta or SRK dies still believing n his love in Preity. And ey, I did guess right? Who write storys like this aagain and aaaaaaagain and aaagin? YES ITS THE ONE AND ONLY BOLLYWOOD, pure crap movies with bad acting!

[–] Chrysanthepop 15 years ago

They're both bad but I`ll choose VZ.

(\__/)
(='.'=)
(")_(")

[–] Peter_Young 14 years ago

Love Vz, but still Titanic anyday.

[–] 14 years ago

[deleted]