MovieChat Forums > Stranger Than Fiction (2006) Discussion > Girl was completely unlikable

Girl was completely unlikable


How can a viewer root for the girl? She was obnoxious, repulsive in every scene. She was absolutely in the wrong in treating Crieg like that. He didn't owe her an apology, she did. He did nothing wrong.

She acted like a total jerk in each scene of hers.

-------------------------------------
I own you.https://goo.gl/0avZjB

reply

I still liked her despite all that.

reply

She was obnoxious, repulsive

You clearly come from a different planet from me.

Edward

reply

She started off that way, but by the end of the first day was apologizing for her attitude.

reply

Damn, TVippy! You are one ugly mother *beep*

Schrodinger's cat walks into a bar, and / or doesn't.

reply

Why, thank you! My answer: https://youtu.be/VcgRaf38uCQ?t=11s

-------------------------------------
I own you.https://goo.gl/0avZjB

reply

You're welcome! :-)

Schrodinger's cat walks into a bar, and / or doesn't.

reply

I thought Maggie was very lickable.

reply

Oh geese! I bet you're a piece of work in any relationship. What's wrong with civility, with giving someone the benefit of the doubt, with choosing the high road? What's more important to you, always being right? Or being in a healthy relationship?

He was smitten with her at first sight. And unlike you, Harold didn't dwell on negative thoughts. Cost him next to nothing to make this investment. As payoff, he was able to experience her true inner beauty.

reply

I agree with the OP completely. Tattooed, short-haired, childishly 'anarchistic' thinking without taking responsibility for her actions 'aww, why are you auditing me, you mean man, although I didn't pay my taxes??!!1'..

That nasty attitude, that ugly much, that 'I do whatever I want and you can't audit me for it', toxic attitude.. and we're supposed to be rooting for her?

Maybe I've been seeing too many japanese women in TV shows and movies lately, but the contrast is like ton of bricks being dropped right next to you suddenly. It's jarring and scary to think that someone thinks THAT is the kind of woman men should go for.

I would be too disgusted to even vomit at her general direction.

To point out the other side of the coin - women, especially 'empowered female dogs' like her, would _NEVER_, ever go for a simp like Harold (who, may I point out, isn't even REAL)! I mean, the whole 'relationship' is 100% unbelievable, no matter how you look at it.

Don't even get me started on the whole, boring and stupid 'cookie' thing..

Heart-shaped cookie at the end?! Just let ME jump in front of that bus, and don't let me live.

In other words, kill me already.

reply