Frankly I don't think Lindsay did a very good job here :/ I like her acting generally, but this part almost seemed like a backwards cameo, how does a girl so obsessed with suicide and not talking to many people suddenly throw on a shawl and rhyme with things said score hen even her poetry was of a non-rhymeing style?
Then she talks about her dad (who we never get to understand) she's okay with her moms ex-boyfriend and she cries over a dead guy and still no one says anything about it.
Strange
I would tend to agree with you, but I don't think it was Lindsay's fault. The part was kinda shoe horned into the script. He character didn't make sense, I agree. But that was on the writing. I thought she did a great job in her part. Her part just sucked.