MovieChat Forums > Jacquou le croquant (2007) Discussion > Is it really as bad as the featured revi...

Is it really as bad as the featured review?


Just wondered, because it looks good and I enjoy foreign films. Otherwise, can anyone suggest any notable foreign cinema for me? Aside from the usual suspects city of god, amores perros, run lola run and Asian cinema etc.

Also, I was wondering if anyone could tell me whether this film will be released on Region 2 for the UK?

----------
Pulled down by the undertow, never thought I could feel so low

reply

I think this movie is very good.

reply

I find the movie beautiful, and while it is not perfect, I enjoyed it very much. The actors are amazing, esp Ulliel and Gourmet who played the Priest. Also the two leading ladies did quite well.


The Movie-Fanatic
http://themovie-fanatic.com

reply

Come and See, Vitus, Jestem, The Italian, Witte van Sichem, Pelle, several others.

reply

It's not that bad, it's worse!

Worst movie I've seen in years.
If you have 2 hours and a half to loose, go ahead...
If you're lacking some sleep, watch it...
If you expect something decent, drop it, this movie is crap.




Fear is my curse. What's yours?
I was born without a conscience.

reply

cool thanks! i'll be looking these up.

----------
Pulled down by the undertow, never thought I could feel so low

reply

No, it honestly wasn't as bad as the featured review. Sure, it's a tad long but I think the acting was wonderful! Young Jacquou, Léo Legrand, is very talented.

reply

I disagree with the featured review, I think the movie is really interesting to watch, and the cinematography is just AMAZING!

reply

i've heard about the cinematog quite a lot, i might see it just for that :D

----------
Pulled down by the undertow, never thought I could feel so low

reply

I'm sure u'll like this film! I found it inspiring & the scenery is beautiful. Ending though was a bit strange in my opinion!

"You stick with me son and you'll do alright"

reply

Honestly, this is one of the best movies that I've seen in the past few years. If you expect mindless action or super deep story, well sorry but it's probably not for you. I, personally, think that it's just a piece of art, the acting, the music, and especially the cinematography, the details, the characters just really affect you. As I said, one of the best movies that I've watched lately and every time I see it again I enjoy it even more. One more jewel from Europe.

Dessy

reply

I just finished watching this movie. This movie is not as bad as some of the reviews make it to be. Its definitely not the best but is definitely not the worst. The cinemotography was well done as praised by other reviewers on the board. The artistic direction with set and costume also very good. I got the impression from some of the bad reviews that they were comparing it to the French mini series and maybe this is why they didn't give it a good review. I have never seen the mini series of Jacquou le Croquant, so I watched it with no expectation and I enjoyed it. I didn't notice the bad acting from the actor that played the adult Jacquou. His acting wasn't memorable but it wasn't distracting from the movie. For me I found the actor that played the priest who adopted Jacquou to be the most memorable character for me and the best acted character. To those who can't decided to watch it because it got some bad reviews. Watch the trailer. If you find the trailer interesting than go out and rent it. Taste is subjective especially with foreign films. As for recommandation of other foreign films, these are the ones I have enjoyed over the years of watching alot of movies: Malena (Italian...the beautiful Monica Belluci and Morricono does the score), In the Mood for Love (Chinese...a plodding love story of unrequitted love. Not everybody will like this movie it's slow, but it has this nostelgic 60s feel that utilize Nat King Cole in its score, beautiful chong-sams and beautiful cinemtography. The chemistry between Maggie Cheung and Tony Leung as two lovers that can't be just adds to the beauty of this film), Nine Queens (Spanish...I think. Loved it. Smart script.), The Vanishing (French...Disturbing in a subtle way), Shiri (Korean...Broke box office record in Asia ousting Titanic from its 4.3 million record in 1999. I am surprised Hollywood hasn't ripped this movie off yet. Its good but don't read the synopsis of it because it will most likely spoil the ending.), Oldboy (Korean...another goody in a NC17 way. The twist hits you in the face so hard you couldn't even see it coming. Apparently hollywood is doing a remake of this. Trust me. It wouldn't be as good.) Infernal Affair (Chinese...the Departed took this award winning HK movie and remade it into a Hollywood version. I perfer the original HK version because its grittier and the ending is not the good guys always prevail ending. If you enjoyed the Departed watch this version and you mignt be delightfully surprised), Devdas (Indian...this one got mixed reviews, but I loved it for its gorgeous costume and set. Plus Aishwaya Rai looks gorgeous in this movie.)

reply

Movie are great, not for all..

reply

This is a minor masterpiece. Don't take Didier for an absolute.

reply