MovieChat Forums > Lemming (2005) Discussion > This is the explanation (MAJOR SPOILERS...

This is the explanation (MAJOR SPOILERS)


1. the only dream sequence is the one with the house of lemmings when he crashes his car. This is also set up as a red herring so that we wonder whether he's dreaming the rest of it.

2. the spirit of Alice takes over Bénédicte, which is why B sometimes becomes quite nasty yet can't remember it later (eg when she hangs up on Alain)

3. Alice takes over Bénedicte every now and then, eg beside the lake (when she knows what Alice said in the lab... though we may wonder at the time that perhaps Bénédicte saw the scene via a webcam... this is another red herring).

4. Bénédicte DOES have an affair with Pollock but only when possessed by Alice's spirit. She then returns to Alain, gives him the key, and appears as both B and Alice, so that he kills Pollock. She wanted to see him croak, remember?

5. Alain comes in and kills Pollock, and Bénédicte is now free of the spirit of Alice, demonstrated by the simultaneous death of the lemming. Bénédicte does not remember any of the possession by Alice. The lemming, rather than having Alice's spirit, represents the passing of Alice's spirit to Bénedicte (and clearly has some of Alice in it, when it bites Alain).

6. What we do not know is whether Alain knows
i. that his wife indeed became possessed, and asked him to kill Pollock; or
ii. that his wife had the affair as Bénédicte and has now forgiven Alain; or
iii. that he (Alain) is having another delusion like after the car accident and the "suicide" of Pollock was another coincidence or a premonition.

We know the answer is (i) but we don't know what Alain thinks. Alain is as confused as the viewer is. Which is quite a neat ending.

See Dominik Moll's interview on the DVD special features (on the R2 release in any case) for confirmation of this. More or less.

reply

great analysis of the movie, thanks!

reply

... the spirit of Alice takes over Bénédicte, which is why B sometimes becomes quite nasty yet can't remember it later (eg when she hangs up on Alain)
That's not compatible with the laws of nature. Is this a ghost story? The movie misses a clear point here.

My interpretation: Only the scene with the many lemmings was real and the rest was a dream

reply

> That's not compatible with the laws of nature.

agrea

well this place (hills around toulouse) is pretty windy except when the "pico-z cam" is on mission ...

And tell me how attractive is Alice , she looked already dead to me ?

may this be a nice hitchcock, lynch and lewis caroll tribute but I only rated it 6/10


I had better played to the lemmings video game

--
# http://rzr.online.fr/q/Movies # Watch copyleft movies ?

reply

A thousand thanks, Tristan-2!! Watched this movie and was eager to see the ending but due to the slow pace i fell asleep.
But you answered all my questions.

reply

My explanation is, only the credits were real and the rest was a dream. But perhaps, maybe, the credits were a dream too?

"Alas, poor Hollywood, I knew him.
Alas, poor Hollywood, I knew him."

reply

Some very interesting comments here and on other threads. We watched it on cable tonight the attraction was Charlottle Rampling.

David Lynch comparison - yes - agree.

Closing song - a clue. How much is dreaming?

reply

I agree with the explanation and really enjoyed the film. Was very similar to cache though. Not quite as good

reply

Nice explanation, indeed, but what about the house of lemmings, what does it symbolize? And how did Alice get this strange ability to possess Benedicte, was she a witch or did the lemming cause it?

reply

She was the leader of the lemmings, who once every 30 years appears in human form and fu cks over every human in sight. The houseful represented the eternal angst of lemming existence when forced to move from their Scandihooligan homes.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Because they are intelligent viewers who seek meaning in their lives.

--
"Den Gleichen Gleiches, den Ungleichen Ungleiches."

reply

I'm glad someone has explained it a bit, having watched it until 4am on Channel 4 last night I was left more than a little confused by what happened in the last half an hour or so.

reply

This is all a bit literal. I think the film uses a number of devices and abstractions to convey a study of adult relationships and how they may falter with age.

"I'ts happening again!"

reply

Yes, that's exactly what I thought, too. This is a neat little modern Ghost Story. For me it was quite obvious, that Benedicte was possessed by the ghost of Alice.
Very clear in the end, when she says that she dreamed that Alain was sleeping with Alice, but he was thinking it was with her. Even more interesting is the fact that she was pregnant after all. Who is the father, Pollok or Alain? ;-)

reply

All interesting and welcome explanations. I was under the impression that when the lemming died and came back to life, and Rampling/Alice blew her brains out but came back within the body of Benedicte, that the house had spirits.

I was waiting for the VW Bug to come alive as "Herbie goes to Southern France!";-)

Seriously, does anyone know why Benedicte kept staring at the boy across the street as he kicked the ball against the wall? All replies, serious or not, welcome.

reply

I think Benedicte kept staring at the boy across the street,because he was the one who smuggled the lemming in from Finland.

reply