So what happened?


SPOILERS:

The ending was a bit abrupt without leaving any explanations, so let's discuss it. Let's assume that she was killed by the witch (like the first girl), then the question is: did the people at the hotel deliberately send her to death?
All of them, except for the old woman, seemed cold and hostile and didn't want to talk much about the missing person. My theory is that they needed someone to sacrifice to the witch and conspired against her. Her friend wanted to borrow her necklace with the crucifix (there's a Christian theme here) and before that it was stolen from her room (I'm not sure who took it or why it was given back later). I suppose the necklace protected her from the evil being when her friend led her through the woods, hence why it had to be taken away from her. Another thing to note is that the one person who warns her is the woman who is saying prayers in the night. I was thinking, if there was a conspiracy, do you think the missing girl was sacrificed as well(perhaps like many others before her), or did the hotel people assume that the witch caught her and figured that they have to start "feeding" the witch in order to survive?
Anyway, the film was pretty good and creepy. Nice atmosphere, and some obvious influences from THE SHINING, BLAIR WITCH PROJECT and to a lesser extent Polanski's THE TENANT.

reply

It seemed to me that the protagonist was drawn into the woods, and drawn into the black cave, and drawn into the black basement (of the hotel) and the black corridors (of her dreams)--like she WANTED to go. She was always willingly walking into (you might even say happily exploring) these black, dark places and disappearing from view. She clearly wasn't afraid to go into those dark places--she just went. Some reviewers complained that she should've been acting like she was afraid, but instead she was emotionless. But I think that's the point. I think she WANTED to go into those dark, horrible places. Something isn't right there with that girl. I don't think she's as pure or innocent as she appears.

In fact, I'm fiddling with the idea that she WAS the witch, or at least she was some active part of the darkness somehow (even if she doesn't realize it, necessarily).

SPOILER: I think in the end of the film when she disappears into the woods, she may be going home (not home to her parents on a train, which she says she is going to do, but returning to her real, dark, scary home--the cave, or at least the dark woods). I don't think she is being abducted or sacrificed. She's walking into those cold, horrible woods because she WANTS to. And maybe everyone in the hotel is acting strangely to her because they are maybe a little afraid of her? (Remember the woman who told her to "Leave the hotel" and started saying prayers? I don't think the woman is being nice and trying to save her; I think the woman is telling her to "get away from me" and the prayer is being said as protection against the desk-clerk-girl.) Also, maybe that's why the basement door was locked behind her--to give her that little push to "go back home and leave us alone." Of course, at the very-very end of the film there is that horrible far-away scream (barely audible--I had the sound turned way up), which makes you think she's being attacked or killed as she disappears from view. But if you pay close attention, that PRECISE SAME SOUND is heard throughout the film--3 times--when she is in the woods earlier in the movie. (It is the exact same set of two screams--the first time it seems as if the movie plays it off as a bird or something, like a peacock. But it is the exact same sound three times throughout. Very subtle. Again, I think this shows that this is not her screaming, and she is not being attacked.) I think every review I've read so far about the film has been wrong.

Either way, I don't think anyone can ignore the fact that she was willingly disappearing into those dark places and never seemed particularly upset about it. And I don't get the feeling that she was under some influence either, or under any spell. She seemed to have her wits about her all the time. She seemed very "together" (which is what so many people seemed to complain about because they thought she should've acted more scared or something). But if she WANTED to go into those dark places, then she would have no reason to act scared.

reply

I thought that these things were in her head.
She saw darkening corridors appear, and the big woodtrees, while she was inside at work. Maybe it was real and she was just dissociative - losing minutes of time now and then, but then again: maybe she went into madness at the end and it was her healthy mind that died.




"The Beamer Xperience: 9 feet wide home cinema bliss."

reply

I can only recommend Polanski's Le Locataire (plus Lynch's Twin Peaks and a pinch of Blair Witch) to grasp this film.

Fear is the mother of morality.

reply

That's a very good observation of the repeated sound effect. I have the DVD, and I'm too lazy to watch it again, so I'll take your word for it. ;)

Spoiler alert: I think the fact that her colleague tried repeatedly to borrow her lucky charm showed that there was a conspiracy going on there. It was stolen once but was found again. Maybe that served as a warning to her that she wouldn't be so lucky the next time.

Because of her insistence and maybe stupidity, she was lead to her own demise.

Btw, I have a question, why did the witch doll suddenly appear after the party, after she doozed off?

reply

At first, I must say that, when I first saw this ending, I was enthusiastic. In whole movie is such a brilliant scary atmosfere and this end is like big silent boom and then - straight came end-credits.
But I think, in my opinion it is has something with demonology of the forest.
In movie, we heard that, there is a legend of witch and Devil's cave in the woods.
And Hotel is right in that wood and calls "Waldhaus". And that "darkness, demons and ghosts" of the forest penetrate to the hotel and try to drag the main female character into the darkness. And when she goes at the end to that forest and then comes that scream, she maybe sees the witch or something really "demonic". Maybe like a EVA, her predecessor.

Perhaps, we never will know the truth, maybe there's not even any "truth" and if it's, only Jessica Hausner knows it :-)))

Anyway, I think this is that "spirit" movie. And that is genius :)

reply

In a 2003 interview Hausner said:

"I want to tell a story about a nightmarish situation, at the same time without giving the audience an opportunity to attribute it to a concrete circumstance. The thriller genre was chosen so as to justify a claim that something terrible is happening - this also evokes in the audience a foreboding of what might happen next. But an answer is never provided. I thought it was exciting to say that this is a genre film but it's told realistically and there's no monster at all."


http://www.afc.at/jart/prj3/afc/main.jart?rel=de&reserve-mode=active&content-id=1164272180506&artikel_id=8691

reply