MovieChat Forums > Little Manhattan (2006) Discussion > 7 reasons to believe Rosemary felt as st...

7 reasons to believe Rosemary felt as strongly as Gabe


Having seen this movie several times recently, I wish I could get Levin & Flacketts thoughts on Rosemary's mindset in the final sequence in the boathouse. Here is what I see.

7 reasons to believe Rosemary felt as strongly as Gabe did in the last sequence

1) their feelings clearly grew toward each other throughout the movie. It was obvious in numerous scenes that Rosemary liked Gabe a lot. She even reached out for his hand. It seems unlikely that they would gone to such lengths to show she liked him, if she didn't like him at the end.
2) when sitting by herself at the wedding reception, Rosemary is clearly miserable. Then when she sees him she is first amazed but then overjoyed
3) when he asks her if she might wanna love him to, she doesn't actually deny it, like she would if she didn't have any feelings for him. she merely expresses her undertainty of what to think. This indicates that she clearly
liked him a lot. She just was confused about the idea of putting the label of "love" on it.
4) when she tells him she is very happy he came, her face brightens up
5) she then asks him to dance - something that is very difficult for somebody at that age
6) when they are dancing, she doens't merely hold on to him like a friend, she actually holds him close
7) in the final assessment, Gabe says that love ends - but in doing so, he doesn't say that it wasn't because she didn't like him, but because they were on different roads. That coupled with the phrase "we both knew" tends to indicate a mutual longing for what couldn't be, and a mutual acknowledgement of what had to be - thereby indicating that they knew they liked each other but sadly had to part.

My assessment is that Rosemary felt just as strongly as Gabe did, throughout the movie, and even in the final sequence. The problem was a matter of semantics - as an 11-year-old girl with loving parents (and their soap opera) as role models, her idea of love was undoubtedly idyllic - princesses and castles and rainbows - while Gabe's idea of love, as an 11-year-old boy who was emotionally panicked, was impulsive - "if I care for her it must be a love that has never before been experienced". She knew she wasn't sure what love was, and that his expression was a gross overstatement. He knew he was admitting his feelings. Their truth was somewhere in the middle. They both shared a strong "young love", which is not the same as "true love", but a budding embryo of emotions. But Rosemary was (ironically?) mature enough to know that the emotions they shared were not the full mature version that would come with age.

Some have suggested they parted as friends. I disagree - I think they parted as more than friends. I believe Rosemary will remember Gabe as her "first love" as well.

I can't help but feel that the dialogue would have been more mutually satisfying if Gabe had maintained the typical outlook of kids that age, relating to her on that level to which she knew, telling her that he really liked her, rather than the over-the-top exclamations of love that only served to confuse her more. She was just as emotionally wracked as he was.

I do wish they had included one more scene, of them parting at the end of the reception. It could have solidified their mutual longing for what could never be.

But then again, maybe I'm reading into the ending what I need to rather than what was intended.

reply

I'm not sure if I liked your analysis because I want myself to believe Gabe and Rosemary are definitely more than just friends, or whether it's objectively solid, but kudos, nice insight.

reply

It is a very nice insight, Olion.

I must say that I truly believe in it, too.

reply

They put a lot of effort into how Gabe's and Rosemary's feelings were reflected - particularly in the music. I think each song was carefully selected.

* Only the strong survive - this is a movie about first love ("I remember my first love affair. Somehow or another the whole darn thing went wrong.)

* Map Of My Heart - Gabe is drawn to Rosemary, which ultimately leads to him loitering where she lives ("I always know where I am, and which road loads to you. It's written on the map of my heart.")

* Love - Gabe and Rosemary's tour of the park was the real spark to the relationship. They had both noticed each other before that, but this sequence highlighted their feelings ("Love ... what a silly game we play ... What is love ... I just want it to be love")

* Love Grows Where My Rosemary Goes - Gabe's thought process at successfully making a "date" with her

* Younger Yesterday - their relationship had definitely advanced to a young romantic "love", from an eleven-year-old standpoint ("Love is here it's clear as day. We're not too young to know, we're not too young to find out way.") I think the whole sequence with them travelling up the bike trail, stopping at the little park, and then saying goodnight in front of her place, clearly shows this, and clearly shows that it is mutual.

* Teach Me Tonight - They are learning more about what love, even "young love", really means

* Miserable Life - Gabe's pain at missing her, despite what he tries to tell himself.

* The Very Thought Of You - Rosemary's misery at sitting there alone, and we are led to believe that she is thinking of him.

* At Last - Perhaps indicative that they both know they have experienced "first love" ("At last my love has come along, my lovely days are over")

*In My Life - Gabe would never forget her ("There are places I remember ... In my life, I'll love you more.")

The song "At Last" confused me at first, since they were parting. But when they dance, Rosemary holds Gabe very closely, not like friends dance, but as romantic partners dance. She may have been confused about what "love" really is, but she nonetheless felt romantically drawn to him, and was going to miss him. ("We both knew") I can't help but think, as carefully as the other songs fit the moment, that this one was intended to as well. If so, then it further paints a picture indicating that she recognizes that he was her "first love" as well, and that perhaps it mirrors the Nat King Cole song, indicating that before he came to her, she was feeling lonely, and that now that he came and they reconciled, she no longer felt so lonely.

The problem for her was she was hearing "love" and trying to equate it with adult love, which scared her, rather than the "young love" or "puppy love", the eleven-year-old version, which is only a beginning, and not the same thing. After all, Gabe didn't have anything to compare it to, either.



reply

My mistake, the song listed as "Miserable Life" should be "Lonely Road"

reply

i think if they stayed friends for a long while more, they would of end up being in love with eachother as adults or even teenagers

____________
hey bluebird on my shoulder, Can you carry me over?

reply

---3) when he asks her if she might wanna love him to, she doesn't actually deny it, like she would if she didn't have any feelings for him. she merely expresses her undertainty of what to think. This indicates that she clearly
liked him a lot. She just was confused about the idea of putting the label of "love" on it. --

this one
girls don't think relationships need much words
they're okay with something not too serious at the beginning and don't want the word "love" being used lightly. They like to go with the flow and don't feel any relationship discussion is needed (expecially at the beginning of a relationship) and actually feels that too much talking destroys the mood.

Although a bit of a generalization, male have their stronger emotions verbally (they like to talk, discuss things, rationalize, control...) females have their stronger emotions mentally (they want to feel, imagine, anticipate and in fact girls are known to fraction their emotions, for example by turning off a kiss, in order to make the emotion they will feel grow stronger as they wait)

She loved him but wanted to go with the flow, let the relationship build up on small happy moments like the ones they had and felt like all the spontaneity was being destroyed by his labelling their relationship and declaring like that (on a subconscious level of course)

reply