MovieChat Forums > D-Day 6.6.1944 (2004) Discussion > so few comments ? I thought it was reall...

so few comments ? I thought it was really good


I am watching this again on UK TV HISTORY.
Don't know why they are showing it in January and not June but never mind it is at least a real history programme and not a programme about trees or something.

I saw this in 2004 when it was first shown.

I felt it was worth watching,I know the history and still learned something,at the same time it was dramatic and looked great.

reply

I too watched it last night and thought it was superb.

reply

[deleted]

As much as I appreciated this and in particular the Merville battery assault,I`m really not sure that these drama-docs make truly satisfying viewing.This clearly had quite a lot of money thrown at it and some of the C.G.I effects were pretty good.What I`d much rather see though is a new feature film or mini-series about 6th British Airborne, detailing all the operations on D-day.To include the Canal & river bridge assaults although the latter was taken without a shot being fired.To include all the subsidiary actions including the demolition of Troan,Robohomme and Varaville bridges.Show the German counter-attack on Pegasus bridge.Maybe show actions of 6th Airborne after D-day which hardly get a look-in.Maybe somebody at the BBC or Film4 can club together with the lottery film council and make it-maybe,maybe,maybe-hmmm thought not.

I`ve found the best place for detailed analysis is a good old-fashioned book although channels such as UKTV History,where I was watching this again last night,also provide a good service.

reply

[deleted]

It`s damn frustrating,so many interesting ideas floating around:a WW1 film about the Somme from the German perspective.Interesting as to what the Germans apparently thought about this battle but most historians this side look apon it as a disaster- a disaster not helped by the fact that the British soldiers were explicitly informed NOT to run and probably couldn`t if they wanted to anyway as they were weighed down by a ridiculously heavy kit.This battle taught the lesson,subsequently forgotten, that no matter how heavy the pre-bombardment, a sufficient defending force ,well dug in and crucially given time to recover, would inflict heavy casualties.I subscribe to the view that although the Germans suffered horribly ,it was a British disaster rather than a German one.Verdun is largely looked apon as a French disaster but it was a battle of attrition where the original German intention was to bleed the French army dry.In the event both armies bled each other in equal amounts, although unknown to the Germans, this precipated a collapse in French morale which manifested itself after the Chemin Des Dames offensive.British morale didn`t collapse after the Somme but the terrible casualty rate, in just one day`s fighting, is something that thankfully wouldn`t/couldn`t be repeated otherwise the war would have been lost.

reply

[deleted]

I liked this as well, tho' I have to say the 2nd hour was better than the first. The character recreations early on (like Capa) didn't do much for me, but I'm quibbling. I think in the end it's the real people, the real footage, the real stories that got to me. The red cross made of bloody sheets, wow.

reply