MovieChat Forums > Lost (2004) Discussion > everyone hated the finale, but they didn...

everyone hated the finale, but they didn't?


people have rated the last episode as 8.2/10 on imdb. Dexter and GOT have awful finale scores but Lost always get lumped in with the most disappointing finales.

reply

Lost always get lumped in with the most disappointing finales.
Only by morons who either didn't understand the finale, or morons who haven't even seen the show and only pretend to hate it in order to hop on the bandwagon being driven by the ones who didn't understand it.

And IMDb scores don't mean shit. 8.2 is much lower than it deserves. Just like Dexter and GoTs scores are much much higher than they deserve.

reply

GOT finale was absolutely devastatingly awful. Lost wasn't even close to that bad.

reply

You said it!!!

reply

The problem with Lost was that the whole of season 6 sucked so the finale was like the cherry on top. Wasn´t a fan of the finale but there have definitely been worse.

reply

Season 6, particularly early on, is one of my least favorites, but has several very good episodes. All the episodes about MIB, Jacob, and Richard very well-received.

reply

Agreed the first several episodes are particularly bad. Sayid, having the "sickness" and the temple stuff just felt like unnecessary filler that didn´t have any effect on the overall story. Richard´s flashback was just okay. I hated "across the sea".

reply

"Sayid, having the "sickness" and the temple stuff just felt like unnecessary filler that didn't have any effect on the overall story."

Oh, I hated that shit. Who are these other Others? Get outta here. No mention of a temple or separate group of Others.

reply

lol yep.

reply

In some ways, Lost's finale was worse b/c you still were waiting for a huge payoff. With Lost, you were waiting for a rabbit to be pulled out of a hat or something to be in JJ's "mystery box" besides air. GofT has some of those elements but the showrunners never tried to tantalize you in the way Lindelof and Cuse did. Those guys played it to the hilt but when they finally showed their cards there was no Royal Flush. Dexter isn't that kind of show so expectations were never as high.

reply

JJ's "mystery box"

Which series did JJ stop writing on?

You sound like an idiot with that mystery box crap.

Are Nolan or Kubrick called mystery box because they withold information like in Inception, Momento, Prestige (ends with a mystery box), 2001, Shining etc

Im not saying JJ is on the same level as either, but he didnt write the show. He came up with the concept and ideas.

Story telling that withholds information and unfolds as the story moves along was not invented by JJ.

Another "The final episode didnt explain, why the polar bear skeleton was in the desert" question should be dismissed as, You didn't watch the show so why bother complaining about something you didn't watch or were to dumb enough not to come to a conclusion of why a polar bear may have been in the desert.

I mean, season 3 the main characters were locked in a bear cage where they had to turn a wheel to get rewards.

"what was the smoke monster". It was JJs mystery box of course, or you could just watch the show and deduce what the smoke monster was.

reply

You sound like an idiot with this post that's overflowing with Strawmen.

reply

I'll ask again. Which season did JJ stop writing on?

reply

JJ referred to his "mystery box" himself on his Ted Talk. I think the idea is kinda the same to Hitchcock´s "macguffin".

reply

JJ only wrote the pilot , though him and Damon made an outline for the first season

reply

Exactly, just shows how dumb these people are who shout about JJ and his mystery box while talking about Lost.

He didnt even write it past the pilot, some early concepts and ideas.

reply

I think they're referring to the talk itself, where he brings up LOST, his creation along with Lindlelof, and defends the concept that mystery is more important than knowledge. If you subscribe to "Chekhov's gun", you might not like that approach. And you might find it irritating when Lindelof suggested answers to all our questions would be forthcoming. There are sites devoted to all the flip-flopping and things that went nowhere in the end.

But Lindelof changed his tune and approach with The Leftovers due to the criticism of how he handled LOST, so it's hard to say there was nothing to the complaints.

reply

I liked it just fine

reply

Loved LOST's finale, because they kept it consistent with the entire series.

Game of Thrones final season and its finale do not keep consistency with previous seasons at all, the entire Seasons 7 and 8 need to be decanonized, rewritten, reshot, redone, and this time with 10-13 episodes per season, not a pathetic 7 and 6.

reply

Make up your mind.

reply

I was a faithful viewer of the show, but felt totally let down by the finale. For me it was very forgettable. Guess I was just too "dumb" to get the subtlety of a nonsensical, copout ending.

The entire series seemed to indicate that the audience would be treated to a final payoff, all the loose ends tied together, a reward for putting up with so many unanswered questions, riddles, coincidences, head scratching twists and turns.

In the end, the finale was a big "screw you " to the faithful fans of the show. The writers obviously had NO idea where they were going with the show and no real resolution. It might as well have been written by a bunch of monkeys on typewriters.

Call me dumb if you like. But as far as I'm concerned, people who were satisfied with the copout, lazy ending will accept anything.

reply

This is true. These days when you read about LOST it's mostly used as a punchline for a joke.

Sidebar: I've always maintained that it was Michael Giacchino's moving soundtrack that sold that final steaming turd of an ending and the showrunner's should have kissed his ass and said thank you.

reply

I think the problem for me was I expected a very sci-fi ending. I mean the show introduced time travel in season 5, but instead it opted for a very religious ending where all the character reunite in an afterlife and move on together.

I still maintain that the final season would have been much stronger had they not done the flashsideways, it was frustrating to watch as we only cared about the island timeline and what was going on with our main characters there.

reply

Yes, I don't know if I expected a sci-fi ending. But I expected more than "Well, they're all dead ,this is Heaven. Amen"

The show introduced so many coincidences in the flashbacks where the characters almost met or their paths crossed and they didn't know it. The writing seemed to hint at some big payoff. The characters were not on the island just by chance. There seemed, at least to me, something that drew them there together.

I was thinking of a Twilight Zone ending or something else fantastic and unusual.

One of my ideas was that all of the survivors had relatives who survived another disaster, like the Titanic, and somehow they were drawn together and survived the plane crash.

Something...anything...other than , they are dead. Thanks for watching.

reply

I don’t mind the whole ‘Jacob was recruiting them’ it was almost like he was bored and just playing God a bit, a very flawed character just like all the other main characters.

I think it should have had an ending where Jack lives and stays on the island with Kate protecting the light.

Everyone else leaves the island and goes back to their lives, even Ben who uses his wealth and resources to do some good.

Jack now has the powers of Jacob and can communicate with the dead. The final scene of the show is a final conversation between Jack and his father and Jack comes to terms over his guilt and his father tells him he’s proud of him. The final shot is Jack and Kate walking through the beach wreckage of the plane.

Bit of a Star Wars type ending but at least they could got rid of the boring flashsideways throughout the final season.

reply

Was an island with healing and other supernatural properties not sci fi, fantastic, or unusual enough for you?

reply

I was also expecting something like the Twilight Zone or something.

I never watched GOT but I always say LOST and Dexter seemed like they were competing for the best series with the worse finale!

I was SO MAD after watching the finale that a week later, decided to watch them again, in case I missed something important or could see it differently and my teenage daughter came out and asked me why I would do that again and she was right!

I loved that show so much, I even went to my Cineplex for the live Q&A...I watched each episode twice, so I could spent one viewing just clue searching. I felt really disappointed.

reply

I don't think the word copout means what you think it does.

reply