MovieChat Forums > The Alibi (2006) Discussion > stay away, save your money

stay away, save your money


this film, intended for a theatrical release, instead headed
straight to the bottom shelf of the local video store from where i
unfortunately took it and regretted it for the next 90 minutes. i saw
about 1.000 movies, but this hits the bottom 5. so i go immediately to
my computer to save at least the time of others. the plot is very close
to nonsense, the acting is uninspired and they are talking every single
second in the movie, and nearly any sentence is dumb.
i congratulate the producers not to start this in cinemas, but they should have burned it.

reply

Easy tiger, it ain't that bad. Yes, this Ellroy wannabe has many a convoluted flaw and contains the most bizarre male lead casting decision ever, concidering the talents of the rest of the ensemble (you have to admire Steve Coogan's relentless attempts at a film career, he still keeps hammering away at it, regardless of how many times his films simply die abrupt deaths...).

But The Alibi gets there, slowly but surely. It's incredibly well-shot on an unremarkable budget, the script while appearing determined to tie itself into a knot ends up more of a bow and repeated viewings allow for that appreciation of the little nuances of everyones performance (step forward, James Marsden, Selma Blair and, as always, Sam Elliot). And can we mention the cast again? It was only this visit to IMDB that revealed Jon Polito (as the 'blink-and-you-miss-him' Photographer) and Jerry O'Connell (the cheating Businessman) right at the beginning of the film. Jon Polito! Jerry O'Connell!! In navels of a cameo! Whoever the casting director was for this flick, he / she must have called in every favour and dirty Polaroid in the book to land this lot (what was it, a quiet month in LA??)

And its frankly always a pleasure to see Deborah Kara Unger in anything, even in yet another cameo in this movie. (Why, oh why, is she yet another mindnumbingly attractive woman who is utterly dismissed as a very talented actor, simply because she IS mindnumbingly attractive?? Or the "Michelle Pfieffer Syndrome", as I call it. I'm looking at you too, Ms. Romijn...) So, don't dismiss The Alibi too harshly - it has lots of little charms wich add up to not the total waste of time 'comzept' will tell you...

reply

I think Coogan is great. He is charming and funny. If he's good enough for the great Winterbottom, he should be good enough for you, you Philistine

Anyway, I thought the movie was cute, but utterly predictable and contrived. Liked the cast. Liked the premise. The execution left a bit to be desired. It was trying to be The Big Lebowski and turned out to be a mildly amusing TV movie.

It's a cold and it's a broken Hallelujah...

reply

[deleted]

I agree in every single point.


reply

Jerry O'Connell probably did the cameo because he is married to Rebecca Romijn.

I think Steve Coogan is a fine actor and not mis-cast here. My one problem with him here is that with dialogue so important to the plot, his accent and the sound quality/editing was such that this American had difficulty following him at times.

reply

I have to say, I'm willing to see this movie, and just put it at the top of my Q, purely based on the fact that Henry Rollins is in it. That's enough for me. I'll watch anything that man makes. I have a bit of a man crush on him, I guess.

reply

I agree It's not brilliant but it filled the time nicely for me - also has some very funny dialogue.
"I need a piece"
"A piece of what?"
"I mean a gun, I need a gun"
"Well why didn't you say so snoop dog"

reply

This is by no means the most amazing movie I have ever watched but it is well worth the time it took to stream from Netflix. I think it's oddly funny in a very dry humor what a tangled web we weave sort of way.

All Hail Kripke
King of the Awesome, Keeper of the Pretty

reply

Don't bother replying. OP has posted like 5 times on different boards and basically to say the same thing every time. I think he/she is genetically bored.

For every lie I unlearn I learn something new - Ani Difranco

reply