MovieChat Forums > Nae yeojachingureul sogae habnida (2004) Discussion > Sequel to MSG from twin sister's POV

Sequel to MSG from twin sister's POV

posted 18 years ago by Star_Red
3 replies | jump to latest

I have never read or heard any comments by director Kwak, but I was surprised that noone here has mentioned that it could be quite possible that Kyung-Jin and the nameless girl from My Sassy Girl are twin sisters. (Sorry if this has been already discussed - I have read most of the threads, but not all.)
That would also explain why Kyung-Jin has a photo of the MSG girl on her piano, because that would be her beloved dead twin sister.
Starting from this point Windstruck then would be a sequel to MSG from the twin sister's (Kyung-Jin's) perspective. Since MSG and Windstruck are three years apart, Kyung-Jin's twin sister might have tragically died in the meantime.
It would then also explain Cha Tae-Hyun's perplexed, strange look on his face in the last scene - he is seeing a woman who looks exactly like his deceased girlfriend.

Since I found Windstruck painfully boring and all the gags contrived and overdrawn, I didn't pay too close attention, so I could be totally wrong with my sequel theory. But it probably holds up better than all the implausible prequel-theories.

Any thoughts?

[–] TheHarshAndLastWord 18 years ago

it in no way relates to the MSG universe at all. The director simply
threw that surprise ending in there to pay homage or respect to
MSG, that's it.

If the girl had a twin sister i think she would've mentioned that in MSG.

" I would love to change the world, but they won't give me the source code. "

[–] Desertman84 16 years ago

Windstruck simply placed a lot of references to the classic hit,My Sassy Girl.But it is no way related to it.It was neither a sequel nor a pre-requel.The movie was simply an MSG nostalgia.

[–] jacachu 16 years ago

I've heard this many times. Most people I know who have seen both films has said the same thing, and it's pretty obvious that's what's going on here.

I think in MSG it shows her only playing the black keys as well. It would also explain the strange ending to windstruck.

Everything fits pretty well, and IMO it's extremely obvious that you're spot on.