What is wrong with black people?


I come to this board..and so many complaints about Oprah and this movie...its like can you do a better job? We just take Oprah for granted..it cost $50 million dollars to make this movie...Oprah had to convince ABC to broadcast this movie...But of course..black people being black people we got to complain about something...anything...We can't just be proud of Oprah. and say "good job Oprah..thank you for bringing black literature and history to the masses". We can't be proud of the all black cast..the director. or screenwriter..that worked so very hard on this project. What is wrong with some of us? Are some black people here so bitter and miserable...that they can't enjoy the movie for what it is? The movie is an adaptation from book to film..so of course..there is going to be some things removed or changed. And then there are complaints that Michael Ealy or Halle Berry are too light for the Tea Cake role..Its like there we go again the colour complex issue in black communities. Michael gave the best audition for the role..its not his fault that he got it..The casting director thought he was the best and that's why he won the role..And then people always have an axe to grind with Halle Berry...Halle is the most famous black actress in America and she has star power....I can see why Oprah chose her. If it wasn't for Halle..would The movie pull in the huge ratings that it had? Of course not...without the superstar power of Halle Berry...We should be grateful..that Oprah made this movie...If Oprah never made this movie...I doubt anyone else would....The movie is a complex role..about a young black woman trying to find herself in this world...It discusses the all black town Eatonville...and how the town was put together..This movie is a celeration of black American literature and history...can't people see the beauty of that?

reply

If you look at all of your post thats all you do is complain yorself, mostly about black people. Black people have the right as any other race to complain, its a human trait.

Just admit that you have issues of your own with black people and more specifically black men. Be real with yourself first darlin'

reply

AMEN to the original post

reply

i agree with the first post.

reply

I agree too!!!

reply

So well written bjorkluuto

reply

[deleted]

whats wrong with you guys - all the posts are saying black, black, black... this movie is much more about a single woman's fate than about anything else. and it does have a great message to all women, about finding true themselves.

reply

This movie was the most dreadful book to film adaptation I have seen in a long time. Things being changed is the understatement of the year. They might as well have re-written the book.

"My gift to you."
-Elle Driver, Kill Bill: Vol. 1

reply

What's wrong with, bjorkpluto?

This is her vision of what a PERFECT black movie should be like. Unfortunately she seems to have little regard for quality nor respect for the actual book. She gives a free pass to lazy casting (Ealy is a very good actor who may have given the best audition but casting him as Teacake is as stupid as casting the dark skinned Sidney Poitier as Thurgood Marshall for that miniseries). Bjorkpluto also does not understand that it just isn't black people who take issue with the bungling of great books when they are made into movies. White people complain about stuff like that all of the time so why should black readers be any diferent?

reply

Why do you assume that all people commenting on this movie are Black?

Baffling

reply

I don't see anything beautiful about things that don't make any sense.

reply

I really feel what you're saying about this movie and black people, but Oprah is a honkey-loving-fake-ass-bioatch! I hate her dumb ass. You know what I don't understand? Why is she alway playing in movies where she's a slave or a poor black woman? That bugs the *beep* out of me. She just so *beep* fake. I know she hates black people. I watch one of her shows and Tony Braxton was on there and Oprah was like you wear a weave just puttin her on blast. Then another show Tom Cruse was there and was jumpin all over her couches like they wasn't *beep* and she sittin there laughin. She dumb and I hate her.

reply

I did not understand the latter part of your post. =/

reply

I agree with bjorkpluto in his well written summary. I appreciate seeing Black literature brought to film, by whatever means necessary. To tell the truth, I was enticed to read the book, by Ealy's performance alone...which makes me eternally greatful that he was chosen to play the part of TeaCake. I realize in the book that TeaCake was darkskinned and tall, but Ealy's performance was on target. I'm glad Oprah made the effort to bring this production to the screen. I'd heard of Zora Neale Hurston before, but had never read any of her books. I've now read TEWWG, Mules and Men and The Complete Stories. I'm presently waiting for Every Tongue Got to Confess. These are books I may never have read, had Oprah not brought the book to film and Michael Ealy portrayed a winsome TeaCake...I think the main connection, Ealy had to the character TeaCake...was the intricate combination of masculinity, adventurer, beauty and devotion...a treasured combination in a man...no insult intended.

I also agree that Black people are missing the point in this film and Oprah's effott in producing it. We are quick to lament the scarcity of productive roles for Blacks in films and television...especially roles depicting love between Black men and women. Hollywood shies away from the pairing out of fear of audience disapproval. It's thought that Black on Black love interests, would make the film, a Black film and White movie goers don't pay to see Black films. I guess the true value of Black consumer base doesn't extend to films.
I read about the Renaissance of Zora Neale Thurston and formerly unheralded works of Black History and Folklore, after a Black literature teacher named Alice Walker, read that she was buried in an unmarked grave and began a search for her grave. She felt an unmarked grave was an insult to a Black American literary presence like Hurston's.

So I co-sign bjorkpluto's assessment of Blacks missing the point in the celebration of Black literature and History. I've been inspired to search out and read more works, I would probably have overlooked without the incentive Oprah brings with her bookclub offerings and productions. I think it's important to look past surface and petty thinking and begin to see value where we can find it. I have to say, after watching "TEWWG", I gained a broader interest in the folklore of Black America...and since then...I have seen the story of "Rosewood"..."Beloved" and "Queen". I take opportunity to search out stories and history about Black America's past. Oprah may have some issues with ego...but her actions speak for themselves, and I for one am glad for her financing and promotion, that presented this film to the public and to me.

reply

What is wrong with you that you would make the general assuption that all black people are complianing about this?

Whites,Persians,Latinos,Chinese,Indian,Native Americans...in ALL RACIAL groups people complain. Doesnt mean its everyone.

Its people with a narrow minded mentality like you that are the problem.


If people complain let them. I really dont think an ill thought out post on IMDB makes a damn dfference.

reply

did he once say only balck people are complaining no.. but you can't deny that most of these complaints about the skin color of Micheal Ealy and Haley Berry... and Oprah not doing better casting are coming from blacks. people are so quick to point out little flaws and not realize the truth be told Ealy played the hell out of that role...I wish I had me a Tea Cake shoot. he made visual the abundance of a man that's sensitive and strong care free and inviting. You remeber when Janie was younger and saw that Bee polinate the flower that represented the whole premise of this story. It was Janie's transition from a girl to a woman and trhough finding love a real love (marriage) she found happiness and independence the color of thier skin takes a backseat to that. not all people read or even heard of Zora Neale Hurston because of this movie many have found their way to loving black literature

reply

Bear in mind that Janie being light-skinned is the predominate physical feature that alienates her from the rest of the black people whom she lives with. You lose the power of this contrast if you cast light-skinned actors in key character parts that were not intended to look this way.

See no sig, hear no sig

reply