MovieChat Forums > Sin City (2005) Discussion > Woulda been better directed by Zack Snyd...

Woulda been better directed by Zack Snyder.


Look how faithfully and beautifully he directed Frank Miller's 300. Sin City was an awkward mess in comparison. RR could not translate the comic book panels as fluently as Snyder did on both 300 and Watchmen. Imagine how much better it would be if directed by him.

reply

HELL no. You've got to be a special kind of stupid to make that claim, as Sin City is panel-faithful, and that hack Snyder made 300 purely derivative of SC's style after famously keeping Miller away from production until SC became a hit.

Especially given that the recurring theme through every one of Snyder's garbage bastardizations is that he doesn't give a damn about source material and narcissistically attempts to rewrite Shakespeare, so to speak.

reply

Y'know, as evidenced by how horrible Watchmen is and how incredibly divorced from its source it is.

reply

Man of Steel and the sequel were below average.

reply

I dont think this movie can be further improved by anyone.

---
A gentleman will not insult me, and no man not a gentleman can insult me.

reply

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

no

reply

Hell nah

reply