MovieChat Forums > Memoirs of a Geisha (2005) Discussion > who do you think is more beautiful?

who do you think is more beautiful?


So, for you, which are the most beautiful women in this film, and in which order? For me, it's

1. Mameha
2. Hatsumomo
3. Sayuri

hands down.


--- English is not my first language - so, if I make any mistake, please correct me!

reply

1. Hat(By far)
2. Say
3. Mam

reply

[deleted]

Yeah,

Hatsumomo
Sayuri

Mameha - (distant 3rd)

reply

well......

Hatsumomo(Gong Li is gorgeous)
Sayuri(She is pretty)
Mameha


reply

[deleted]

Hatsumomo
Mameha
Sayuri (and also the young girl who plays the young Chiyo)

reply

[deleted]

Hatsumomo
;
;
;
;
;
All the rest.


reply

i agree with you, a_a.

reply

Hatsumomo
Sayuri
Mameha
But couldn't go wrong with anyone of them!

reply



1. Chiyo - Suzuka Ohgo incredibly the only real Japanese female in the movie, and obviously the show stealer.

2. Mameha

3. Sayuri

reply

The fact she's Japanese doesn't make her the most beautiful

reply

1. Hatsumomo

2. Sayuri in a distant second.

3. Mameha in a very distant third.

reply

mm for me its

1. Hatsumomo (she was supposed to be the most gorgeous and she is)
2. Sayuri
3. Mameha (though sh's a close tie with S)

reply

1. Mameha
2. Korin
3. Sayuri
4. Hatsumomo

I LOVE Korin she was sooooooo beautiful


Korin is played by the BEAUTIFUL Eugenia Yuan

reply

hutsumomo - gong li without a doubt



reply

[deleted]

mameha looked kinda old

reply

[deleted]

GONG Li by light years
Pumpkin was cute.

reply

1: Hatsumomo
2: Sayuri
3: Mameha
4: Korin
5: Pumpkin
6: Mother

reply

I agree. Mameha was past her prime.

reply

Hatsumomoo. Gong Li is so gorgeous. And a great actress!

Do you have love for your girl New York?

reply

Mameha- may be older, but aged beautifully.
Hatsumomo- strikingly pretty.
Sayuri- In a close tie with Hatsumomo. Young but still gorgeous. However her eye color slightly bothered me.

"Oh you don't need a picture. Just look up the word handsome in the dictionary."-Big Fish

reply

ALL those women are gorgeous!

like ridiculous...they're great to look at

and their beauty is timeless and just elegant!!!!

i think thats the best kind of beauty

i think hatsumomo
then mahema...just like in the book, beautiful, but still not as hatsumomo!
then sayuri...shes cute mostly

reply

1. Mameha
2. Sayuri
3. Hatsumomo

Get busy livin' or get busy dyin'

reply

1. Hatsumomo( Gong Li is absolutely gorgeous!!!!) AND THE CHAIRMAN LOL!
2. Sayuri( really close between her and hatsu, but very beautiful)
3. Mameha

reply

I think the little girl who plays young Chiyo is really pretty.

reply

mameha... it's just mameha for me

reply

To me Sayiri is the most beautiful of them all.

ECSLFS

ps: I love Cole Sprouse!

reply

[deleted]

1. Mameha
2. Sayuri
3. Hatsumomo

& I agree with music_inspired87

reply

Mameha - absolute classy!!

reply

1. Mameha
2. Hatsumomo
3. Sayuri

Mameha has an elegance to her; she's beautiful and holds this pride and power and modest confidence with her beauty.

Hatsumomo...well, see she's pretty, but she's just...she lacks something. that's all she is, pretty...she's missing an element to unique beauty though, and what makes someone really beautiful is something special, something different from others. I just feel she maybe tries too hard with her beauty or takes it for granted while Mameha is more appreciative of her beauty or more accepting of it, just allowing it to be as it is, not letting it take over her too much.

Sayuri just seem a bit too gentle. nothing wrong with it; she's pretty too, but she just seems a tad bit plain or expected. Mameha and Hatsumomo have more character in their beauty.

I don't know if I'm taking into consideration their character too much, though.

"Stars" -Switchfoot

reply

I've always thought Mameha was pretty, followed by Hatsumomo and Sayuri. In my opinion, I don't think Gong Li looked as gorgeous when she had all that geisha makeup on, Zhang Ziyi looked ten times better when she wore it!

reply

[deleted]

1.Sayuri
2.Hatsumomo
3.Mameho

Each of them had they're own unique type of beauty.

reply

Hatsumomo....*shudders*
I used to respect Gong Li but her recent appearances in American films (all in whore-ish roles) has some how cheapened her beauty.

Mameha, I agree, carries herself like a proper woman and has a beauty that shines through her outward appearance...like a glow of some sort....

reply

Whorish?? LOL. Do you have any idea how many "Whores"(Concubines) she has played in Chinese films.

reply

1. Hatsumomo (sooo beautiful)
2. Sayuri
3. Mameha

They're all pretty though.

www.jlodown.com
www.petitionspot.com/petitions/jlodown

reply

A tie between Hatsumomo (Gong Li) and Mameha (Michelle Yeoh). This is one of the few things I really am undecided about. There are days when you'd like to look at the other more...

Then Sayuri (Ziyi Zhang).

reply