MovieChat Forums > American Dad! (2005) Discussion > Shell of what it once was

Shell of what it once was


Please just cancel it and stop ruining the characters. It's not even the same show.

reply

Why don't you stick to Family Guy. There are LOTS of people who still love the show and enjoy it. Your opinion is meaningless.

reply

Oh God Family Guy is horrendously bad also. It now appeals to the idiot masses the show once mocked.

reply

Sooo because you don't enjoy something it should end? Maybe just stop watching. I still enjoy it.

reply

I plan to.

reply

It's because Mike Barker left the show. That's when the style changed and to many people it stopped being as funny.

reply

Really? Is that when they went to TBS?

reply

Yes. I believe the reason given was "creative differences"

reply

I see he did Terry's voice, that explains why Terry left Greg on the show. Loved Greg & Terry together.

reply

It's strange that he stuck around for the voice so long after stepping down from co-producer.

reply

by JoostinOnline (Fri Jul 1 2016 00:39:46)

It's strange that he stuck around for the voice so long after stepping down from co-producer.
He wasn't credited as co-producer [that I can find anyway]. He was always co-executive or simply executive producer & co-creator or creator for his entire run of the show.

It's not that he 'stuck around' after it was announced he was leaving in November '13.
Terry's last speaking part was A Boy Named Michael & was still production season eight. TBS started production season nine in or a short time prior to November '13 I'm sure, enough time for a disagreement to boil over with TBS & Mike.
Naturally it was recorded prior to the announcement he was leaving. He was long gone from the show by the time his last Terry voiced episode aired in September '14.

reply

It's easy to get mixed up on what happened when. Nobody is even 100% sure what season we're on. 😂

reply

Two seasons into his departure, I think most fans would agree that Mike Barker's decision to leave American Dad was a huge turning point. The way its creative direction changed was noticeable even to casual fans. I personally feel it changed the entire identity of the show, even more so than the move to TBS did. More "edgy" and shock-value-derived humor, less emphasis on character development and absurdist humor. Mr. Barker is sorely missed.

reply

Actually Mike Barker was still with American Dad during this episode so maybe a little research would have helped you not look like an idiot.

reply

danielledip10, you're right about it. This show used to be REALLY funny! To me season 9 was the turning point. Bring back the Roger who was hip, cool, racist and did coke always. Now he just makes dumb comments occasionally.

reply

As much as I hate to admit it, you're right, but I really don't want the show to end on this sort of downturn. I really want this show to continue with the hopes that the humor will return to its former glory but since it's move to TBS, it's added an excessive (and unnecessary) amount of swearing, cringe humor, (too much) pop culture, loss of characters, nonsensical and irrelevant plots that lack substance, and just an all around downgrade (let's not forget American Fung). Barely anything happened in this finale and there was nothing more than a few chuckles which seems to be a consistent feeling for me with these TBS episodes. Jeff's subplot could have been removed completely and I felt like it didn't even need to be introduced. Roger felt very one dimensional and was rarely used, and Stan becoming a DJ to overthrow his boss sounds like a lazy story I would have written about my teacher in middle school. All around it just didn't flow naturally to me. I miss moments like Roger's dog the bounty hunter character, Tender Vigilante, Stan's Spring Break, and basically everything the old episodes used to be. I've watched this show non stop since it's original run and it's return after the gaps of airing. Like many others, I'm pretty sure the departure of Mike was also the moment where the show declined. Outside of a few episodes, the past couple seasons there haven't really had any memorable episodes for me. It's sad to see something I love so much turn into a shell of what it used to be. I probably wouldn't even watch the show anymore if I hadn't ran through the old ones on Netflix 500x but I stick around with the hopes it'll go back to its old style and refrain from rubbernecking, texting while driving, DJing, selling out, and everything else it's been doing since the move.

reply

You summed it up perfectly.

reply

The moral of the story here is that TBS ruins anything they get their hand on.

TBS wanted the show to be a less funny, intelligent version. Mike Barker wanted to retain that humor and intelligence. TBS didn't like that, so Barker left. It's sad really.

I am a thread killer. That's what I do. I post in a thread and then it dies.

reply

Good for him for sticking by his beliefs.

reply

Lol its still better than family guy

reply

Same as Family Guy.

reply