MovieChat Forums > The Onion Movie (2008) Discussion > the difference between parody and satire

the difference between parody and satire


I've read quite a few posts on this board, mostly by dumb kids saying parody and satire are the same thing. One poster actually calls them synonyms. They aren't and I'll clear it up. Also I should say that this movie is actually quite funny.

Parody is always an imitation, be it of a movie, writer, genre or person... usually exaggerated for comic effect. thats it.

satire can be parody. but satire uses humour (often exaggeration, why it gets confused with parody) or irony to criticize or point out the stupidity of something or someone. It is often used in controversial topics, such as politics (political satire is something everyone has heard of).

Satire often uses humour BUT you can have satire that is not funny or meant to be.

in the movie take the melissa cherry bits. This is both parody and satire...
It is a parody of britney spears, exaggerating her sexual lyrical content and how she portrays her self in overtly sexual ways for comic effect.

It is also satirizes American pop culture. An actually controversial subject like whether or not young children should actually be idolizing a dumb slut like britney spears. it uses humour to expose and criticize this aspect of american culture. Making it satire.

reply

If you want to see good satire, check out Brass Eye if you can, it's a series of mock documentaries about different subjects. Genius.

Some examples...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRRw1ERj2Gc&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFNs2mOkKzc&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIkLc4xR6Vg&feature=related

...you see, stars that clear have been dead for years, but the idea just lives on...

reply

wow. you're so smart. 'mo.

reply

We're all thoroughly impressed with your keen ability to distinguish and discern "parody" and "satire". Please enlighten us with more of your intelligent words.

reply

.... "intelligent words"? I thought he was just trying to clarify something that people were really getting wrong. The dictionary terms of satire and parody are different, and I didn't catch a hint of pretentiousness in the OP's tone, so why are you being so sarcastic?

"Tremendously OBNOXIOUS! No blotches! My telephone-watch will leave bartenders topless!"

reply

What sarcasm? There's pretention in that OP for sure.

---
Scientologists love Narnia, there's plenty of closet space.

reply

That's as accurate a definition as I can give. I'm too mentally lazy to think through the definition of parody at the moment, but you're right it's different from satire.

reply

Well, this is an area where connatations can muddy the waters. But, based on dictionary definitions (which is limited I know), it seems that parody hinges more on the concept of using imitation as a method generate to humorous effect.

Whereas, satire hinges on having human vice or folly as its subject.

So, you could of course use parody, and other comic devices, as part of your satire -- but as has been noted, it's not strictly necessary for satire to be humorous, whereas parody seems to be intended primarily for humorous effect.

Eh . . . that's my two cents.

-... ..- -.. -.. .... .- -....- -... ..- -.. -.. -.--
Will

reply

Well I will gladly admit that I didn't know the differences of the two.
Until now that is.
I'm glad that it was cleared up.

-----
Anything you say can and will be held against you...in the court of Robocop.

reply

Brilliant post, Tristan! I often see "parody" and "satire" used synonymously, but they are often two very different things. Your examples with Melissa Cherry show how they can intersect.

reply

parody = mockery of an obvious target

satire = makes a political or social statement

pedantic = overly concerned with minute details or formalisms

ostentatious = intending to attract notice

reply