MovieChat Forums > Stauffenberg (2004) Discussion > What is best ? This or Valkyrie ?

What is best ? This or Valkyrie ?


Is Valkyrie alot better than this version or would it be wise to watch the original.. I must say apart from "hunt for red october" and "the boy n the stripped pyjamas" translated movies normaly suck..

Plz what is best, this or Valkyrie ?

reply

I'd have to say that "Valkyrie" is better, because it's more exciting. However, after seeing it, I wanted to know more and watched "Stauffenberg" on Youtube. It's a lot more detailed and seems more accurate as to what that day was really like for the conspirators.

So, I'd say see Valkyrie first. If you enjoy it and want to know more, check Stauffenberg out.

reply

Valkyrie is better and more watchable, shows the different plotters better, is more suspenseful and less boring and is more accurate in places. However, Stauffenberg's wounding in North Africa and the spot details of July 20th are actually more accurate in 'Stauffenberg'.

"It is not enough to like a film. You must like it for the right reasons."
- Pierre Rissient

reply

However, Stauffenberg's wounding in North Africa and the spot details of July 20th are actually more accurate in 'Stauffenberg'.


yes, maybe, but the RAF strafing attack on Staufenberg in North Africa is very crudely executed in CGI in "Staufenberg", in not refining that a bit they got the movie off to a poor start.
Of course I'm sure that CGI war-vid has improved since 2004.

reply