MovieChat Forums > Christmas with the Kranks (2004) Discussion > They could have easily just done both

They could have easily just done both


Go on their cruise and celebrate Christmas. I only say this because Nora really seemed to miss their Christmas traditions, like decorating the house, having a tree, giving money to charity, etc. I don't see why it had to be all or nothing. Decorating the house wouldn't have cost them anything since they already owned all the decorations. Just don't buy any gifts, go on the cruise, celebrate Christmas, and everybody is happy.

I know it's just a movie, but I didn't see any need for Luther's "all or nothing" attitude. It didn't need to be so extreme, especially since Nora clearly missed their typical Christmas rituals.

reply

I thin it was about more than the money. Once you get started on decorating then it's just one more thing until you've done it all. We always have Christmas at my mother's beautiful home, but she's downsizing and has her home on the market. So, we are having Christmas at our less beautiful, much smaller home this year because she doesn't want to decorate at all even though her home is gorgeous at Christmas. She knows it's a slippery slope for people like her, and I think it's the same for people like Nora.

"There is nothing in the dark that isn't there when the lights are on." - Rod Serling

reply

I get what you're saying, but I guess I see it as that they could afford it, which made the total boycott of Christmas kind of unnecessary, particularly because Nora was clearly missing their usual Christmas traditions. Yes she was happy to save money (who doesn't love saving money?), but considering they spent $6000 on Christmas the previous year, and the cruise was $3000, there should have been some wiggle room for them to at least decorate and buy a Christmas card or two. Skip the gifts & take the cruise instead, but it needn't have been so extreme.

Most things in this movie are really extreme (like the neighbours), but this irked me more. They had a wreath on their door which Luther rips off at one point. Was that really necessary? Heaven forbid they have one Christmas decoration hanging up!

reply

Oh, you're right. That's exactly what normal people would do...and actually do! I mean a family with grown kids going on a cruise for Christmas, with or without the kids going along, really isn't that unusual.
A friend of mine's family did it last year.

The entire thing was just ridiculous.

Luther had his head up his ass from the beginning. Not with the cruise idea, but with how he went about it. The letter sent out to his co-workers announcing that he would not be celebrating Christmas was presumptuous, so I can see why it annoyed people. Their passive-agressive reaction, though, was worse.
Same with the insistence on not decorating or doing any Christmas activities at all. More for the sake of Nora than the neighbors, though. As you said, she clearly was missing doing Christmasy things, and they could have decorated some and taken part in a few activities like giving gifts, and come in well under budget (assuming their budget was the same as they spent on Christmas the previous year).
Their neighbors, as far as I'm concerned, should go jump off a bridge, though. Harassing someone for not putting up Christmas lights because of a stupid competition? I can only imagine the discrimination if a Jewish or Muslim family moved into the neighborhood. And being pissy because the Kranks aren't throwing the lavish party that everyone usually goes to? Talk about entitled!

For that matter there was absolutely no reason not to tell their daughter about their plans. Her original plan was to be out of the country anyway, so why shouldn't she know that they've decided to travel for the holidays also? Heck, even when she called from the airport it made absolutely no sense that it was so urgent she never find out that her parents had planned to skip Christmas. If she's old enough to get engaged, she's old enough to learn that her parents have a life even when she isn't around.

reply

They could have at least put the lights up so that the neighborhood would still have a chance in the annual contest, Dan Ackroyd's character even offered to put the snowman up for them but they wouldn't even allow that.

His letter was also very asinine and uncalled for, nobody at the office had to know what his holiday plans were.

If she's old enough to get engaged, she's old enough to learn that her parents have a life even when she isn't around.


Well she was dumb enough to get engaged to a guy whom she's only known for less than a month.

reply

She'd known him from some other time before. They mention it at some point.

"There is nothing in the dark that isn't there when the lights are on." - Rod Serling

reply

Yeah, on the phone she says something about how they went to prom together & her parents had met him at her dorm a couple times. I got the impression that they'd known each other for a while, but only started seriously dating recently.

reply

I actually don't have an issue with his letter to his coworkers. The reason for this is that he is upfront. He isn't buying them gifts this year and therefore he expects no gifts in return. However, I will say the part about not accepting gifts is pretty cold hearted. Some people don't give gifts expecting one in return.

reply

I think part of it was that Luther was sick of being forced to participate in Christmas. He was stubborn about people telling him that he needed to decorate and do christmas stuff. Yes he could have done all that and also gone on the cruise, but he wanted to make a point.

reply

Maybe it was just too painful for him to do it all without Nora?

reply

The movie's message was really mixed up. By naming them the "Kranks", it implies that they (or at least the husband) are Scrooge-like characters who hate Christmas. That was not the case--they just wanted to celebrate it in a different way in a different place. But the movie implied that they were indeed cranks if they didn't want to stick with the old traditions that everyone in the neighborhood had, and by giving in at the end they restored the correct way to celebrate, so that even Santa approved.
There were several pretty funny scenes, nevertheless.

reply