MovieChat Forums > In Her Shoes (2005) Discussion > When Rose told the story that Maggie had...

When Rose told the story that Maggie had remembered differently...


When Rose told that story from their childhood Maggie says she can't remember a man in the store where their mother spilled all the caramel. I know that what this goes on to show is that Maggie can't remember all the details and that this "happy" memory is actually a tragic one that shows how deranged their mother was. It also shows that Rose even then tried to protect Maggie from the conflicts and problems in their family and the world.

Still, I wondered is there any particular significance to that man that Rose mentions and that Maggie can't remember?

reply

Maybe just that Maggie just remembers her mother in that fancy dress and everything. She doesn't remember the outside world, and who strange their mother seems to outside world's people. Rose is old enough to see that.

reply

I read the book, and when Rose is recalling that memory, she mentions that the man looks at her in 'a certain way'; with a slight look of pity and patronization. Rose caught him looking at her mother and I took it to be the defining moment in which she: a)saw her mother reflected through the eyes of others, and b)realized her mother was different. in the movie, though, none of this is mentioned and it seems like that line is only there to show the funny communication style of two sisters!

reply

I thought that scene was the most telling of the movie, as it revealed where, in Rose's development, she was compelled to protect Maggie. She at the time was older, wiser(beyond her years)and could pretty clearly see what they were dealing with vis a vis their mother. With Maggie at the age she was, she no doubt perceived the whole episode as a great adventure; Rose, knowing better and experiencing the pain that comes from that knowledge, wanted to spare Maggie that pain and took steps to do so. When Maggie says she doesn't remember the argument between her parents, Rose responds "You were in your room, with the record playing"...Rose, no doubt, placed her there.

reply

Plus, when Maggie says to Ella about her mother being like no other, referring to the tiara in her lunch, instead of any food. Maggie ses it as fun, but you can see the concerned, knowing look on Ella's face. Perhaps this is why Maggie turned out the way she did and Rose the way she did?

Also, this went hand in hand with her eating habits...

"Oh, I don't eat breakfast." When Maggie is asked Ella what she'd like for lunch.

reply

You're absolutely right! :]

"Fasten your seatbelts, it's going to be a bumpy night!"

reply

wait did the mother commit suicide? I dont' understand wut her problem actually was. WAs she mentally ill, or had a disease like pneumonia or cancer? Wut exactly was wrong with her and did she die purposely or was it unexpected?

reply


I just saw this on television, so I think I can fill in a couple of details.

After the disastrous trip to the department store, the father was angry with the mother; Rose put Maggie in another room with the music turned up loud enough so that Maggie couldn't hear the argument between their parents. At that point, Rose must have been old enough and smart enough to realize that her mother was impaired.

Previously (it had been revealed in a conversation between Rose and her father) the mother had gone mostly without psychotropic medication because she disliked the "fogginess" that it produced, and the father went along with this so as to please her. However, in that argument, it appeared as though the father finally was threatening to commit the mother. Two days later, the mother killed herself in a traffic accident; the grandmother got a letter a couple of days later saying only, "Take care of my girls." However, she did not because her son-in-law prevented her from doing so.

It does seem as though the mother was bipolar. No normal adult would stay up all night making a huge amount of fudge and then take it in first thing in the morning to a major department store and expect to be immediately given a booth to sell the fudge. However, that is exactly the kind of thing that a bipolar person at the height of a manic episode would do; the illness gives one enormous energy and self-confidence, to an absurd degree.

As to why the mother killed herself, either she had crested the mania and was beginning the descent into depression, or she couldn't face the possibility of commitment (and, obviously, being medicated as part of it) or both.

reply

Yes, this was a subtle and well written suggestion of Bi-polar I disorder (manic depression) which would be both exiting and scary disoriented to live with as the child of a bi-polar parent. Nice when writers don't do the movie-of-the-week approach to writing mental illness.

Suicide is always a risk with B-polar I. Depressions can be sharp and deep with self-destructive impluses.

reply