MovieChat Forums > Missing in America (2005) Discussion > Filmed weakened by gross overstatement, ...

Filmed weakened by gross overstatement, pounding of audience


Understatement works much better.

Why such a gruesome ending? Ending on reconciliation of girl and guy who lost an eye would have been much stronger.

Visit to Vietnam Soldiers' Memorial not needed. Film should by self-contained.

Glover's performance was very good.

Odd characterization of girl. Too cute & precious at times.

Convenience-store clerk superfluous. She makes idiotic statement to the effect that since everyone suffers loss, Glover should not feel so sad.

reply

I completely agree. The death of Lynnie and the subsequent two scenes turned a very good movie into cheesy crap. The moment the Glover character called Lynnie back and she did not listen my involvement was completely gone.

reply

I rewatched MIA a few nights ago, except for the gruesome, nonsensical ending. I agree the girl's character belonged somewhere else. She was perfectly charming, but nowhere believable under the circumstances. I thought the scene for the BBQ was good, but the individual elements of the film simply don't hold together. Too many distractions that go nowhere. The film seems to depend heavily on the audience's "inherent" sympathy and understanding for these lost souls. That works, somewhat, until maybe about halfway through. It felt very contrived, manipulative, and the ending felt like a complete betrayal of anyone who continued to be engaged. I would love to know the director's and/or writer's thought processes, what exactly they were hoping to convey. And, though I admired Linda Hamilton's Sarah Connor, seems like her character was another dead end. What an opportunity squandered!

reply