MovieChat Forums > Dark Water (2005) Discussion > I have zero sympathy for Natasha (SPOILE...

I have zero sympathy for Natasha (SPOILERS)


As harsh as this may sound, I didn't feel one bit sorry for her in the film. I know she went through the pain of her parents just abandoning her, and her death was due to their negligence. However, it doesn't justify taking someone else's mother the way she did and leaving another little girl motherless, or the way she was going to drown Ceci right in front of Dahlia unless Dahlia did as Natasha wanted.

Natasha went through something that no little girl should have to go through, but when she knowingly put another girl through worse, it's hard to feel any sympathy for her. She may have been lonely and in need of a mother figure, but it was no excuse for blackmailing Dahlia into drowning herself and leaving her daughter, when she knew how close they were.

reply

That was very selfish and cruel of Natasha.

What's your favorite scary movie?
http://janayime.tumblr.com/

reply

I agree totally. Natasha wasn't even cute and had an evil look on her face in every scene she was in. She reminded me of the unlikeable Samera from The Ring movies. I too thought it cruel to try to drown the poor innocent little girl in an attempt at emotional blackmail.

reply

She's evil. End of. Bar none. And the worst part is, she got away with it. Fucked up ending.

reply

That's kinda the point of these types of vengeful ghost movies, though. Isn't it? Emotional trauma sometimes creates monsters out of people.

And it's particularly horrific when those monsters are the ghosts of children, because they have these mighty powers to do great harm, but they never grew up or developed emotionally enough to know how to really temper or control their feelings. People piss these kids off, kill them, and then effectively give them a magical armory of weapons and unlimited ammunition. That's a recipe for disaster.

It's tragic what created these monsters. But in the end, they're still MONSTERS.

reply

Natasha had free will. She can control herself like she easily controlled the elevator and the water in the apartment building. She knew what she was doing.

reply

I didn't feel much sympathy for any of the characters.

It just reminded me what a Zoo New York is. Ugly people in an ugly city. The constant emphasis of every man lying to the Mother isn't found in many other movies but it rang true for New York.

The mother kept leaving the little girl alone to wander around and get into trouble. Watch your kid lady - how come she doesn't mind you?

reply

Yes, but Natasha was an angry, lonely child. Most children at that age are selfish. She saw that Ceci had a mother who loved her, so Natasha wanted the same thing.

Children are/can be irrational. The same is true of Natasha, so it IS justified what she did, even though it WAS a selfish thing to do.

~~~

"Could you please get your head out of your ass? It's not a hat!" - Pitch Perfect

reply

That still does not excuse her evil actions. If you chose to deliberately sabotage a strong mother-daughter bond just because you are without one, that's YOUR choice and YOUR choice alone. Natasha is responsible for her own behavior. Everything she did was deliberate, cold and very calculating and should've been held accountable and punished for her actions. She knew better.

reply

Really, zero sympathy? A little girl in an empty apartment who doesn't understand why her parents are suddenly gone one day and never come back? Who struggles and drowns all alone in the dark? (We got a glimpse of that delightful experience in the washing machine scene.)

Then she gets one friend who can see her and play with her, but that kid starts getting punished for even talking to her. Oh, plus she's moving away.

Then Natasha finally gets someone to just do one simple loving thing like reading her a story but that person bolts after ten seconds to go be with her real daughter.

Of course she tries to drown Ceci! Either Ceci ends up being her co-drowning permanent playmate or maybe Ceci's mother will pick up where she left off with the storybook and the cuddling. Suggesting Natasha developed a diabolical blackmail plan is overthinking by several steps; she's just lonely and desperate.

It's Dahlia who says, "If you stop, I will stay with you."

Listen, no one likes kids less than I--I go diving for the remote if I even hear a squeaky little voice on tv--but this girl's story was a heartbreaker.

reply

Agreed. As far as compulsory down-beat endings in horror go, this one had alot of grounding. A solid ghost movie, deserving of at least 6.5/10

reply

I came on here to say the exact same thing.

I can't understand why she created all the fuss because she didn't have mother, but caused another girl to lose her mother. It's double standards. I felt sorry for her until that happened.

reply

I agree. Natasha should've faced accountability and harsh punishment for what she did. She knew right from wrong and knew it was an evil thing to do.

reply