What was the ending


I read and hear enough miserable real-life stories without needing to see real-life, horribly sad, endings in movies. Unfortunately they leave me feeling terrible for weeks.

While I really enjoyed the movie I turned the DVD off at the point after Gabriella returns from signing her song. She's just parked her car in the garage and her husband has come in and closed the garage doors.

Reading the comments on this board (I read Swedish) I get that Daniel dies, but what I don't get is how brutal is the ending (or at least all that I haven't seen) ? Am I going to be left with nightmares?

Many thanks to anyone who will answer this, or point me to a description of the ending so I can decide whether to continue.

reply

I just saw the movie... please pick up the DVD and finish it..

You'll survive the ending (as well as the rest of the movie)

reply

Yeah, even if the ending is bad it's still kinda leave a feeling of awe (as well as sadness)

Jag utgår från att du kan svenska: Slutet var ledsamt men ändå när hans drömmar blev uppfyllda i det sista ögonblicket...?
Kommer du ihåg scenen där Lena säger att hon ser ängeln hos honom? Då får man en ledtråd, döden för dem var inte så farlig. Det var bara ett steg till nästa grej.
Döden var som en frigörelse (fick jag en känsla av).

Pick up the movie and finish it -and see it again and you get the hints hidden in the plot. Then it won't be so bad. I promise.

reply

Of course, one person will say that he dies and another that he became unconscious and another will say that he closed his eyes and just listened to the music being piped in through the loudspeaker on the ceiling. Yes, the last image he sees or thinks of are the fields of grain – this time without bullies – only his mother picking him up to comfort and love him.

I like to think that he lived, but I don't think that's what the screenwriter had in mind. First of all, M in Sweden makes some very good points about Lena seeing the angel in him, and we all know the literary themes about angels coming to earth, sent on a singular mission, and then returning to Heaven. Daniel, dark and "strange", is very different - an outsider – and was so from the very beginning when he was young. Swedes of his generation were rarely named Daniel. He does not have a name like Svensson or Karlsson or Olsson or Sjöholm or Sjöberg. His name is Daréus, an uncommon name, if at all a Swedish name. (Is he perhaps Jewish?)

In literature, in the genre of the heroic quest, a hero often leaves or is chased out when young, but returns to "conquer" and to save people. It's no coincidence that the writers gave the main character the name Daniel, just as the Biblical prophet who performs a miraculous deed and eventually redeems his people. Daniel "saves" many of the people of the town by who he is and how he changes the old ways they have looked at life. And who is the one person in the town who, broken and in pain, asks him, "Why did you come here?" but Stig the pastor, as if to wonder if it was the Devil who sent Daniel back to turn people's lives upside down. Along these lines, but in an opposite manner, why might it never cross the pastor's mind that perhaps it was actually God who had sent Daniel to make them happy and to liberate them from the enslavement of a bitter, vindictive man, who even kept his own wife miserable and unfulfilled? Remember when they are together in bed and the pastor's wife asks him twice, at least, "Do you take this woman?" but she uses the older, Biblical Swedish form of the word take, the one used when people are married in church.

On the other hand, we can also turn this idea on its head. Remember the painting on the wall of Lena as an angel? In a sense, she can be the angel who delivers Daniel, who awakens him to love, who by her openness, honesty, and purity of soul teaches him to trust, who helps him finally feel that he can love another human being. Therefore, I don't necessarily agree with M here when she says, "Döden var som en frigörelse", because it seems to me that it was actually life and the belief in life that was the agent of liberation. Gabriella's song is all about life and a passion for life. It was Daniel who awakened this love of life in them all and this feeling of being reborn and now able to appreciate life after all the repression, victimization, bullying, violence, and lies to which many of the townspeople had been subjected for so many years. And now, having found love, why would Daniel see death as liberation? He was no longer in pain. Remember how he rode his bike through Innsbruck, head high towards the heavens, happy and in love, just recently liberated enough to tell Lena he loved her?

In a sense, that's why the ending – when people in the audience get up and join the Swedish choir – is really much more symbolic. The music, begun by Tore, the brain damaged boy, was so beautiful, one could imagine fellow singers being caught up in the beauty of its sound and wishing to sing along. Music has that contagious and magical quality, doesn't it? The choir beginning to sing spontaneously without Daniel, is, of course, metaphoric: Daniel gave them their wings and now they are free to fly. They don't need him; he has shown them that getting in touch with their inner beings, their own ability to make music, to find their own sound, their own voice, is what gives them not only their freedom, but the courage to remain free. Here they were on stage, waiting for Daniel to show up, worried and becoming nervous. Look at Lena, who had just been told how much he loved her. But once the music begins and the choir begins to sing, they are fine. No one is panicking, no one is worried. They can do it on their own. Even Lena.

reply

Daniel, dark and "strange", is very different - an outsider – and was so from the very beginning when he was young. Swedes of his generation were rarely named Daniel. He does not have a name like Svensson or Karlsson or Olsson or Sjöholm or Sjöberg. His name is Daréus, an uncommon name, if at all a Swedish name. (Is he perhaps Jewish?)

Wether Daniel is a name uncommon for the characters generation I cannot answer. But for the surname; sure names like Olsson and Sjöblom is typical highly common Swedish family surnames. However more latin sounding names like Dareus have been popular since centuries and are not that uncommon, and is not jewish in origin. It was especially adopted by people successful in academia. They also mention that his agent changed his name when he was 15 years old which could suggest he had in fact a more typical swedish surname.

reply

He says in the beginning that noone in the village will know he was from there because his manager or his lawyer had his last name changed when he was 14. Presumably after his mother died.

reply

Wow, you really understood this movie! Thanks for this!

reply

You wouldn't really know how beautiful this movie is and what it is saying about life if you don't see the whole movie. I hope you have seen it by now.

I saw this movie last night (I even bought the sountrack!)
My life has been uplifted. "There is no death."

reply

You told you bought the soundtrack, where did you buy it? I can't seem to find it annywhere... I live in the Netherlands and I'm willing to pay for shipments.

Thanks in advance!

reply

He was gay, married the preacher and abandoned the choir and took the church service weekly....terrible movie, don't bother watching the end. Send me the DVD as it is not available here in Melbourne!

reply

SPOILER DELUXE!!!!

Here be spoiler. Don't read further if you don't want to know the ending! I don't agree that he dies. I don't think that he does. Or .. hmm .. maybe I just don't want to see it. YOu can't deny that last breath but can't we all just agree that he only pass out and when the credits is rolling paramedics come and saves the day.

Other than that the movie was a pretty obvious and full of cheap shots, but I still liked it! Oh, and I loved it how he depicted the small town with everyone talking and knowing about everyone else, and with the 'raggare' in his Volvo etc.

reply

it's true. you don't even know what happens. Does he die or not? but if he dies we know that he is not scared anymore. He has found peace and he has realised his dreams, dreams he never knew he had. and if he survives, things can only be better. his arrival in his old town changes not only hime but also the whole mentality of the town. And that is important. we shouldn't be narrowminded, but open up to new impulses, and embrace life in different ways that what one might be used to, and our lives just might be enriched.

reply

Remember that Daniel gave up his musical career after he suffered a heart attack. He was told that his heart was worn out. There was nothing that the doctors could do for him.

Daniel returned to the village that he was born in to die. And he did die at the end.

Yes, for a while he was only semi-conscious and listening to the music, but there is no mistaking that he stopped breathing and sighingly relaxed into death as the choir sang.

reply

My mind played tricks on me and I thought the ending was:
Him in the fields holding up his and Lena's baby.
Cheers,
LG.

reply

I thougth the ending was cheesy and unrealistic. What was with the singing? Do you really believe that the people would start singing in the middle of their preformance? I really liked the movie, but the ending could have been better.

reply

The movie was so good that i was very afraid that the end would be very corny. When they were already in Austria I was already thinking of how the ending was going to be. When the end finnally came it was incredible, one of the bests endings i´ve ever seen. Im sorry i disagree with you but the ending is perfect for the movie, and when you think the movie is gone, it comes back to the beginning, he finds himself in the yellow field.

reply

To answer "What is up with the singing?" Daniel's goal in music was to find a tone that would be the symphony of the heart - one that would touch anyone. It starts with the one choir mementer and spreads throughout the auditorium. At the last, Daniel reached his goal.

reply

The 'song' it ended with was very intense to me. It felt like an ocean of voices collapsing over me in waves. It sounds like I can imagine the songs in heaven would sound like...

If you missed that, because of your fear of a bad ending, you missed the climax AND the point of the movie. The point is that there is no need for fear! :D

reply

>I thougth the ending was cheesy and unrealistic. What was with the singing? Do you really believe that the people would start singing in the middle of their preformance?


Remember the title of this music contest - "Let the People Sing"? That's what it happened and what Daniel wanted and worked for. He rejected the idea of putting their singing in competition. There should be no judges. Everyone is equal.

reply

Exactly Right. You got the point of the movie. So wonderful of an ending. The choir competition still happens most years..and that "song" was one of the best spirit gathering experiences/scenes ever.

reply

It is not clear if Daniel dies or not, but that is not important for the story. The important thing is that he found love and shared love while he lived.

reply

if(!) he dies, he dies a happy man ..

as he has finally found love ..

and

was able to fulfill his real dream of music for the first time - the thing he was searching for his whole life

reply

Exactly!

I totally second every word of that, agricola64.
And saying this, how can such an ending leave any viewer sad for weeks?

Let's face it: A medic already told him that there is little to no chance that he'll grow old. His heart is already too exhausted. Death will get him anyway in the near future. And so how can he possibly better end his life while being in love, finding his musical achievement at last and knowing that he really made a difference for some people? I would love to die that way!

Keep on watching this film. No matter how cheesy it may appear from time to time. Overall it's a very good one which can leave you with some invaluable truths about life.

And that's a great thing.

reply

"Ending" of a movie, by definition, is when the movie stops, i.e. the last visual image you see on the screen. How you interpret that final visual image is another matter.

The REAL ending for any movie (or real life, for that matter), is when ALL the key characters in the movie have died. And that applied even to cases when they tell you "...and they live happily ever after".

Cheers

reply

I believe Daniel dies happy... with smile in his face, but that hole in his head... I think it was little too much.. :) Anyway, I was fascinated by the ending... the whole singing... the harmony and the balance.... it was great. We all should start living our lives :)

reply

I had goosebumps and the hairs in the back of my neck stood up in the final scene where they all found their "sound" and the rest of the choirs joined in.

A truly brilliant film, with great acting.

reply

Daniel doesn't die. He just finds a way to the little boy within (it is Daniel who lifts up him self as a little boy in the last scene) - so he can live his life without fear - there is no death - and therefore no fear of death - so it is possible to live without fear

reply

Death or salvation? Hmm, there are so many films that leave us with this question in the end... What that should tell us is probably that it doesn't really make a big difference. "Fulfilment" of ones life, ones tasks, ones Telos, but also of ones finite space of living-time converge in one central scene...

reply

[deleted]