MovieChat Forums > 3:10 to Yuma (2007) Discussion > 1957 version or 2007 version?

1957 version or 2007 version?


Which version do you like better?

reply

Original.

I know it's because how movies are made today, we have to find a happy ending,
but the original was to the point.

Also, I think Crow and Bale were miscast.

reply

1957

reply

The remake was good, but the 1957 version was better.

reply

2007 version for me. I love all of James Mangold's films and I think this is on par with the Coen brother's True Grit as one of the best Western remakes. I like the original too, though.

reply

^^^ Same.

reply