MovieChat Forums > 3:10 to Yuma (2007) Discussion > A remake better than the original.....

A remake better than the original.....


...this was way better than the original...and I love classic westerns...

reply

horse poop.

reply

I agree. Watched both of them, a couple days apart, and while the original version is very good, the characters in the new one are a bit more developed, and the action scenes are truly exhilarating. They took the basic story elements of the first and just expanded on them in every way.

reply

Then the original must have been really *beep* because there were some really stupid moments in this movie.

reply

The 1957 version was superior in almost every way.

reply

I believe this is one of those "opinion" things, where neither side of the argument will never, ever truly be correct.

As it's all just a matter of opinion and personal taste in the end.

reply