MovieChat Forums > Yes (2005) Discussion > What a FANTASTIC movie

What a FANTASTIC movie


im sorry but did this film excite anyone else as much as it excited me?
It touched me in such a way. The way "he" made "she" so happy. This film made me feel every emotion under the sun.
I laughed, i cried, i smiled..... words arent enough.
"he" was such a beautiful strong character i thought.

reply

I also loved it. I received the DVD as a gift and had no idea what to expect. I was greatly moved and enchanted by this film and am so happy to have it in my collection. You're right about no words being enough, I can't think of a single way to describe the way this film has touched me. It's now at the top of my favourites list.



"I'm not bad, I'm just drawn that way."

reply

Sorry, I am not trying to insult anyone, but I thought this was unbelieveably stupid. I just watched this last night. The iambic pentameter conceit just DOES NOT WORK and hence is like fingernails on a blackboard throughout the whole damn movie. I am a big Joan Allen fan and I agree the "atmospherics" of this were beautiful, but all I can say is, nice try. I admire Sally Potter for her willingness to try different things, but just because something is different doesn't mean it is successful.

reply

This movie was such a pleasant surprise! I actually found the iambic pentameter an interesting choice. Most of the time, it isn't really noticeable, a testament to Potter's skill, but even when it does seem artificial it's reflective of the fact that this is a film with a definitive point of view. Instead of trying to trick the audience into believing it is witnessing something objective, Potter acknowledges her own biases.

And um... Joan Allen is fantastic.

reply

[deleted]

I thought the iambic pantameter was wonderful. It gave it its own flavor, took it from being a very nice romantic drama to a movie with the feeling of a modern day Shakespearean...well, romantic drama. I adored it.

Every time you read this signature, an orphaned puppy gets fed into a meat grinder.

reply