MovieChat Forums > Home of Phobia (2004) Discussion > read this before deciding to see 'Freshm...

read this before deciding to see 'Freshman Orientation'


Go to rottentomatoes.com and check out the reviews. They are some of the harshest and dismissive reviews I have ever read. The message? The movie is an amateurish slop of poor writing and poor directing. Just about every review described John Goodman and Heather Matarazzo giving a brief relief from an otherwise tedious story. Most ugly of all, many of the reviews from larger media groups dismissed the film as just not funny. Just not funny.

And if you read the painfully pretentious director's notes on the Freshman Orientation website (complete with the pre-requisite "vainly-posed" headshot), the sheer awfulness of the movie comes into even sharper focus. If Shiraki believes he really achieved what he claims to have achieved in the conception and production of the film, then he is even more deluded than most Hollywood parasites. Its a good thing he felt validated at Sundance, because I doubt he'll ever get much validation again.

I saw it at the Los Angeles Gay and Lesbian Film Festival and agree with most of the negative criticisms. I can't find one redeeming observation in any of the more positive reviews. The performances by all three of the "standouts", John Goodman, Rachel Dratch and Heather Matarazzo, were all terrible. All of the acting was awful. But, to be fair, the actors had to work with a very poorly written script, amateurish in both tone and content and excruciatingly obvious.

reply

I haven't read the reviews at RottenTomatoes, but I have seen the movie. And, you know what? I liked it! I'm a gay man of a certain age so I may have missed some references to current fads and songs, yet I found the movie to be enjoyable. Yes, the movie did have some comments that were less than "Politically Correct" and I wish the filmmakers hadn't included them. Perhaps Jay Leno was one of their advisors?

"That's one a the two things I need right now."

reply

Hey Redilirvi, you should rethink whether you are gay - and I am watching this movie now - so obviously could not wait to write a response - but this movie was offensive ON ALL levels - to pretty much every oppressed community. some of my favourite actors are in this - and I feel real sorry that they have to include this on their resume. The writer should consider seriously doing something else with his "career" - and I have a few suggestions. People, do not waste your time

reply

I'm sure this movie was offensive to some people, but I (straight female Christian, if that makes any difference to anyone) adored it. I didn't expect much from it at all, but it had so much heart, loads of character developement, and it had me laughing out loud several times.

If you're looking for something like American pie or Road trip, this might not be your thing, but I don't see how it's bad at all.



-Cheerleaders are dancers who have gone retarded-

reply

I paid a dollar for this movie on DVD from a bargain shop and I watched it.... I didn't expect much from it. The DVD cover looked promising (Similar to Juno's) and yet it was one of the worst flicks I've seen in a while.

I think for same sex attraction folk out there, I think there is obviously some relativity there so It might pass as a decent production for them.

reply

hate to burst your bubble egf, but even to us ssaf there was no relativity! Although fortunately no sexual orientation, gender, body image, intellectual capacity, physical ability or ethnic group was given even the remotest positive representation in this what passes for a film.

reply

Gay man here and I have to say it wasn't that bad. I laughed at it and enjoyed watching it. Was it perfect? No. Were there things I wish they had done differently? Yes.

In the end though, I couldn't help but laugh at it and like I said, I did enjoy myself.

If you love someone, set them free. If they come back, nobody else wanted them either.

reply

Agreed. This film just wasn't funny. I found the humor to be way too crude and dumb, plus the characters were all generic types and the ending could be seen from a mile away.

I'm a totally bitchin' bio writer from Mars!

reply

The scene where all the men exchanged the egg mouth to mouth was hot.

reply