MovieChat Forums > Cocaine Cowboys (2007) Discussion > Max Mermelstein made out to be a villain...

Max Mermelstein made out to be a villain.


I thought it was silly how Rivi was saying, "he had a face you couldn't trust" or whatever. It had nothing to do with his appearance. Jon Roberts ended up snitching and they never presented him this way. I bet 90% of the cartel members would have snitched to avoid jail time if they had been caught. Max even says to Roberts that he has heat on him before getting pinched. If he was a willing informant, he would have sought out the Feds instead of the other way round.

And after getting pinched, it was business as usual for Roberts and Co. I mean really did they think nothing would happen considering the guy that masterminded the whole import operation got taken by the Feds. This seemed so ludicrous to me. The first thing I would do is pack up my money and get the *beep* out of dodge.


Furthermore, I am amazed how Max's role in the operation is kind of glossed over. I was reading his wiki entry and apparently he was so highly regarded in the Medellin Cartel, that he was the only American allowed to sit into their meetings. They don't really emphasise how important he was to the operation at all during the documentary.

reply

Who did Roberts snitch against?

reply

You should read the "The Man Who Made it Snow" by Mermelstein.

Max goes into this further and how he was treated like family by the Medellin Cartel. He also talks about how part of the reason that he started cooperating was because he felt responsible for ruining so many lives and that he felt his days were numbered anyway...It definitely throws a different spin on his situation, more so than the CC documentary does.

I also remember reading Max's book and thinking that some of the stories that Jon Roberts tells in the CC doc, are told differently in Max's book.

reply

At the end of the day, they're all criminals and can't be trusted. You have to take everything they say with a grain of salt. Even the guy who killed the kid turned snitch. Most criminals do.

reply

"they're all criminals and can't be trusted. "
BINGO

reply

Rivi ended up cooperating too.

reply