MovieChat Forums > The Corporation (2004) Discussion > The Big, Bad, Assumption Here

The Big, Bad, Assumption Here


The glaring error in this documentary is that it ascribes all the "evils" that corporations seem to do to the fact that they are...corporations.

That is decidedly wrong. The issues are the result of BUREAUCRACY.

Anyone who has had to deal with, and/or was screwed over by, say, a government bureaucracy will surely know that.

Hence the old saying, "You can't fight City Hall".

Or the standard whine of the clerk behind the desk, "I'm only an employee here. I don't make the rules, I just follow them."

(One old Russian Czar once complained, "I don't rule Russia. 10,000 clerks do.")

Corporations have bureaucracies, so they have the inherent problem that all bureaucracies have: The nameless, relentless, momentum of the bureaucracy to just continue to operate, exercise its authority, self-perpetuate, and grow.

That's the REAL cause of all the "pathological behaviour", to use the expression in the movie.

It's the "system", all right, that often seems to be heartless. But it's the BUREAUCRATIC system, not the corporation itself.











reply

When the corporation itself is responsible for the creation of legislation and laws (through lobbying and "campaign contributions") which both benefit the corporation itself, or protect it from being held accountable for its own actions, then the corporation very much can be held to blame for both the system, and its actions within it.

reply