Great movie


I loved this movie. But I have question. Do you think the main character made it to America or was late and went back to the girl? I got the feeling he went back to the girl.

reply

I think knowledge of the ultimate choice would ruin some of the beauty of this film. He is on a road to dreamland and has been enlightened to realize that a beautiful dreamland already exists for him. I think we all find ourselves at this crossroad and ultimately we make a decision and can not look back. I like the fact that the film leaves us at that crossroad.

reply

i agree. the point of enlightenment (hence, the monk both telling him the fable and providing the humorous proof of its truth in the main character's life) is what the film is really about.
i see this need to know "what happened" again and again all over the imdb boards. some people just can't handle open-ended narratives.

gregory 072107

reply

He fell of a cliff.

reply

What I firmly believe is that Dondup (the main character) did is that he went to a festival, and I think so for several reasons:

1) He made conclusion from the monk's story that woman was very disrespectful of his husband, and since Hinduism and Buddhism are faiths that (almost at all) don't respect women, and cultures there are very patriarchal, he certainly wouldn't like for him to happen what happened to the old man.
He is to America what an old man is to a young woman. He has background, tradition, wisdom and deeper understanding of life in general than of those in America. He would end up there in somewhat similar fashion. Hence, why the end of the monk's story is, dreamlike. It could have happened or Tashi was just imagine it. There was still hope for Dondup to "return" to his country and the land he's from, that he so badly wanted to leave
So, he wanted to stay with daughter seeing and realizing that, besides her obvious clarity and wisdom, she chose to stay with her widowed father in village and be at his hand out of respect. In other words, she's not trickster as Deki was;

2) He fell in love with girl and she knew that she was going there with her father, therefore went there as well to meet her;

3) He started to appreciate and like the monk, because he both helped him to get closer to the girl and because of his cheerful nature. He made a trip for him and learned him a good lesson. Also, the monk was heading to festival himself so the "fun" was guaranteed;

4) At the end of the movie Dondup gave a conclusion to another story even before the monk was about to start to talk, and he gave it in ironic manner, like: "OK man, the fancy chick in expensive car didn't care at all about me, I'm going to America to pick the apples. Why should I do it when old man gave me his apples for free, and beautiful young girl gave me half of it by herself, she cooked and took care of me and I'm respected and kind of celebrity in the area because of my position. Why should I look for anything more?" I get the feeling like: "Been there, done that." All that with his smile;

5) He just connected with all the people he met on the road. Almost all of them were going to festival, so goodbye boredom and fancy useless crap, welcome fun in my own area! :)

In my opinion this movie is about respect. Respect based on different natures of people and appreciating them because of both their virtues and faults, and not based upon material wealth and amount of cash on their bank accounts or wallets.

I just sooo liked this movie! Full of symbolism and it was enormously relaxing for me after all the crap that is coming from Hollywood and other movies from, mostly, Western Europe that are so full of violence, useless sex and bad humor.

If you are into this kind of vibe, when it comes to movies, I suggest you to check out Urga, Shadows of Forgotten Ancestors, Ashik Kerib, Milarepa, The Horse Thief, After the Rains... Also, Hero, The House of the Flying Daggers, Samaria, 99 Francs were great, but they are more well known.

reply

He is to America what an old man is to a young woman.


Interesting take; I had not considered this.

I interpreted the monk's story as Tashi falling for the allure of Deki being like Dondup falling for the allure of America: something he thinks he wants, but hasn't really thought it through (with potentially negative consequences).
Tashi was spoken of as being distracted by women; recall the posters in Dondup's room.

Your analogy of Dondup in America being like Deki's husband trying to hold on to his wife is a different approach; I'm not sure it's really the primary analogy the director was going for, but it is thought provoking.

reply