MovieChat Forums > Piggy Banks (2005) Discussion > incest between brother and sister

incest between brother and sister


am i right in saying that john and gertie are borther and sister? well isnt that sorta wrong that they slept together and didnt even think twice about it?

You can be drinking the wine today, but picking the grapes tomorrow."

reply

What's an incest compared to all those murders?

reply

the movie is stupid

Sarcasme Rulez!

McDreamy was doing the McNasty with McHotty? that McBastard

reply

I am not bothered by it myself. They are both of age and the main point is its consentual. I loved their relationship as siblings and how they care for each other.

reply

It's really troublesome and disturbing that the director seemed to just gloss over what was going on as if them sleeping together was no big deal. Finally here's one time where i really wanted to hear a commentary from a director on a dvd, and there isn't one.

reply

Just for the record, they were half brother and sister. Guess that's only 50% incest??

reply

Yeah..that was/is disturbing...I guess they all got the bat chit crazy gene from their Dad...anything goes!!!

reply

it would be worse for the brother not to since that would make him gay; the sister of course was setting a trap

reply

The way that was written it sounds like you agree that being gay is so horrible it's better to sleep with your sister to prove to her you're not.

I'm sure that couldn't possibly have been your intention.



Movies are IQ tests; the IMDB boards are how people broadcast their score.

reply