I doubt this is referring to Jed at all, the sociology seminar parts are to give a commentary on Joe's struggle to accept the science of love faced with the artistic romantic notion of love being a mysterious magical thing.
Both scenes concisely show the deterioration of the relationship between Clare (Clarissa) and Joe. He is describing himself most definitely but he is also describing the fundamental differences that he and Clare have in their approaches to love. this really doesn't come out in the film as much, Clare's character is really underdeveloped and so you can't really get to see her perspective, whereas in the book Ian McEwan literally puts the reader in Clarissa's perspective for a chapter, to great effect. She is has very romantic ideals of love whereas Joe is a rationalist. They are totally incompatible in some respects and yet they can still fall in love - this really confuses Joe, not able to just accept things as being just inexplicable. Everything has a cause and a physical origin, love to Joe has no other origin than chemicals in the brain and no other cause than for keeping two _compatible_ people together to raise a family and give heir genes the best chance of survival down the generations.
"Are these people just deviants?" Has more meaning in that he is questioning whether they are fighting biology, fighting science because the impulses for procreation should make us fall in love with the people to who we are best suited, in personality as well as physically.
Of course it is more probable that Jed in fact takes his words here in the wrong way - the whole thing with Jed showing hinting on violence towards Clare starts after this scene, and it could be said that Jed feels that he is freeing Joe from Clare, seeing that he has seen Joe intimately describing the failure of his relationship with Clare to his class, unaware of Jed being present. This is a theme that creeps along in the book, Jed always seems completely harmless physically, it's just an undercurrent in his character, being such a needy pathetic creature it's hard to imagine him lashing out like he does in the film. But I digress.
It hasn't even occurred to Joe what Jed's intentions are at this point, and it would be a different story if Joe actually understood why Jed is acting the way he is, this in itself is why Joe reacts like he has cracked a conundrum when he discovers de Clerambault syndrome. He is scared and intimidated by things he can't understand and this is what rattles him so much with Jed.
Anyway I could go on and on about the interactions between the characters in this book, but I'll stop here.
Basically, This scene has nothing to do with Joe falling in love with Jed, quite the opposite in fact, it is about Joe falling out of love with Clare.
reply
share